Bad essays or bad letters of recommendation or something.

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Apr 8, 2021
3:52:23pm

DwigtA2RM Contributor

Bad essays or bad letters of recommendation or something.

Report problem with this ad

DwigtA2RM

Previous username: Freeloader
Bio page: DwigtA2RM
Joined: Aug 14, 2017
Last login: Apr 24, 2024
Total posts: 1,819 (50 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Here's the only thing when people say BYU Admissions is a crapshoot...

4/8/21 3:48pm

If someone has high gpa/ACT and doesn’t get in, there’s likely more to the story

DwigtA2RM

4/8/21 3:51pm

Sometimes for sure. But not always. Sometimes it's not because the kid did something to NOT be accepted. Sometimes

unctoothman

4/8/21 3:55pm

I think this is exactly right. I will use my son as an example.

sunspot

4/8/21 4:04pm

Completely agree. I know for a fact that many kids' parents or hired individuals

Fargo

4/8/21 4:17pm

I'd love to get rid of the essay. Or if you must keep the essays, have an formula with an auto-cutoff that is some

unctoothman

4/8/21 4:26pm

Bad essays or bad letters of recommendation or something.

DwigtA2RM

4/8/21 3:52pm

Yep. Does suck if rec was bad and wasn't their fault but not a crapshoot

4/8/21 3:53pm

Bad rec is a crapshoot if the recommender doesn't tell the applicant "look, I can write you a letter, but I don't know

unctoothman

4/8/21 3:58pm

But student picks the recommenders (except seminary)

4/8/21 3:59pm

They should, yeah. But sometimes they pick someone because everyone else picks that teacher/advisor/etc. Or they pick a

unctoothman

4/8/21 4:05pm

Still can't believe joe bob the seminary teacher can impact whether a kid gets

Fargo

4/8/21 4:18pm

I'm fine with it. But it should be consistent across the board. Y/N answers to:

unctoothman

4/8/21 4:21pm

All my older kids got in without a hitch back in early to mid 90's.. youngest

relic

4/8/21 4:37pm

That’s true, but you can control some of that. I told my son to pick teachers

DwigtA2RM

4/8/21 4:04pm

location, race, gender all play a part... Every system has a natural bias

TheLost

4/8/21 3:56pm

I think you’re misinterpreting those stats.

garyfan

4/8/21 4:23pm

Some fun facts... The Acceptance rate is higher for women (70% vs 64% for men)

TheLost

4/8/21 4:53pm

There is more than just scores. Extracurriculars and leadership are huge. I’d

4thand19

4/8/21 8:51pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad