My Account
Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jun 11, 2021
11:51
:35
am
Remigius
All-American
My main concern is stepping back
Especially at this point. We are seen as a level above G5 and this would be seen as a step backwards. High risk, low reward move.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Remigius
Previous username
BYUHoopster
Bio page
Remigius
Joined
Feb 25, 2003
Last login
Apr 25, 2024
Total posts
14,398 (262 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
If G5 gets guaranteed access to Playoff, BYU MUST join a conference.
Moops
6/11/21 11:39am
In indy we lose all relevance with new playoff. We're already seen as a G5 by
FieroCoug
6/11/21 11:46am
Yep. Indy makes no sense if we have real access to playoff in the AAC. BYU will
Moops
6/11/21 11:49am
If BYU wants to be a force and not a farce it MUST NOT join a G5 conference
DeekLyfter
6/11/21 11:50am
Why? We are already a farce. Last year was the first year we were a force
FieroCoug
6/11/21 11:53am
Have you been a BYU fan long?
Moops
6/11/21 11:55am
Recruiting suffered under Bronco as Indy, but our recruiting has gotten better
DeekLyfter
6/11/21 12:05pm
My main concern is stepping back
Remigius
6/11/21 11:51am
Actual playoff access is a step forward. BBall would be a HUGE step forward.
Moops
6/11/21 11:58am
Nope.
All-American
6/11/21 11:55am
Do you actually believe BYU would be admitted as an At Large to a playoff?
Moops
6/11/21 11:56am
When in the Indy Era would BYU have won the AAC?
molodyets
6/11/21 12:00pm
I am an AAC fan as I follow Houston. BYU could have won and gone to an NY6 2020
Moops
6/11/21 12:02pm
Exactly. Byu hasn’t been shown they can win with an Indy schedule
cougfanz
6/11/21 12:02pm
Let’s assume they wouldn’t. They still shouldn’t give up independence.
All-American
6/11/21 12:23pm
If BYU wants to be the best house cat on the block it should step backward to G5
SLIVER
6/11/21 11:59am
What does BYU give up to join the AAC? What do they get?
JJCoug
6/11/21 12:21pm
The AAC will give BYU scheduling visibility around the country
BYU Fan
6/11/21 12:43pm
The key question is the crystal ball for the AAC - are they on a sustainable path or is this 2005-2010 MW hoops
molodyets
6/11/21 1:20pm
There will be no guaranteed access to the playoff for any G5 team.
Zastava
6/11/21 12:22pm
Uh, literally every source I've seen rumored says you are wrong.
Moops
6/11/21 12:29pm
My understanding is that the highest ranked G5 conference champ would receive...
Zastava
6/11/21 2:00pm
Ok, then we are on the same page. That said, the AAC has dominated that NY6 bid.
Moops
6/11/21 2:01pm
If Boise and SDSU left the MW it would be as bad of a league as the MAC and CUSA.
molodyets
6/11/21 2:03pm
You are the company you keep. I’d much rather play the USC’s, Stanford’s...
Zastava
6/11/21 2:16pm
So is BYU keeping company with UMass & Liberty or USC & Stanford?
BYU Fan
6/11/21 2:27pm
This is a great question considering we lost to UMASS a couple years ago
FieroCoug
6/11/21 3:17pm
We currently have the freedom to play (or not play) whomever we choose.
Zastava
6/11/21 3:40pm
So wrong. As a Houston fan, I can say, without any question, no Houston fan
Moops
6/11/21 3:43pm
Houston is a terrible school with a pathetic fan base.
Zastava
6/11/21 3:52pm
You are a peach. Its been fun, but I am done chatting.
Moops
6/11/21 3:53pm
Have you ever been to a houston game? Those fans and the experiences
FieroCoug
6/11/21 4:02pm
I’ve been to three Houston/BYU games. I despise that fan base almost...
Zastava
6/11/21 4:33pm
We've got 3 wins over you 🙂
molodyets
6/11/21 4:05pm
I believe Navy deliberately chose the AAC over Independence
BYU Fan
6/11/21 4:06pm
We only kinda get to play who we choose.
FieroCoug
6/11/21 3:45pm
That’s not true. We play Baylor, Washington State, Virginia and USC during...
Zastava
6/11/21 4:29pm
I agree with u... but seasons like last one revealed that the majority of fans
cougfanz
6/11/21 4:16pm
I don't trust the committee to ever let a G5 team get an at large bid.
JJCoug
6/11/21 2:29pm
BYU will very rarely need to worry about it.
Zastava
6/11/21 3:05pm
What fun is it playing the big boys if you have nothing to play for and lose
FieroCoug
6/11/21 3:19pm
If you can’t beat the big boys then you certainly don’t belong in the playoff.
Zastava
6/11/21 3:44pm
Obviously but at least in the AAC you could use a game or two and still
FieroCoug
6/11/21 3:47pm
The chances of the top ranked G5 champion having 2 losses is very slim.
Zastava
6/11/21 4:47pm
An undefeated indy BYU will never make the playoff. That's not as
FieroCoug
6/11/21 4:49pm
There’s no evidence to suggest that. A top 6 or 7 undefeated BYU team...
Zastava
6/11/21 4:54pm
Agreed. Just responding to your comment about taking your chances as an at large
JJCoug
6/11/21 3:20pm
We'd only be losing a couple P5 games a year and we'd have something to play for
FieroCoug
6/11/21 3:21pm
lol. no. we don't "keep" their money, NY6 access, bowl access, schedules,
Moops
6/11/21 2:35pm
I don’t think BYU is P5, but I DO think they are better than most of the AAC.
Zastava
6/11/21 2:49pm
That's ok so dont need people who turn their noses up to people
FieroCoug
6/11/21 4:04pm
I would rather have very little to do with them.
Zastava
6/11/21 4:36pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad