If BYU wants to be the best house cat on the block it should step backward to G5

Report problem with this ad

Jun 11, 2021
11:59:15am

SLIVER Starter

If it wants to become a lion it has to stay Indy or join a P5.

Report problem with this ad

SLIVER

Previous username: sliver43
Bio page: SLIVER
Joined: Aug 9, 2016
Last login: Apr 19, 2024
Total posts: 1,723 (12 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

If G5 gets guaranteed access to Playoff, BYU MUST join a conference.

Moops

6/11/21 11:39am

In indy we lose all relevance with new playoff. We're already seen as a G5 by

FieroCoug

6/11/21 11:46am

Yep. Indy makes no sense if we have real access to playoff in the AAC. BYU will

Moops

6/11/21 11:49am

If BYU wants to be a force and not a farce it MUST NOT join a G5 conference

DeekLyfter

6/11/21 11:50am

Why? We are already a farce. Last year was the first year we were a force

FieroCoug

6/11/21 11:53am

Have you been a BYU fan long?

Moops

6/11/21 11:55am

Recruiting suffered under Bronco as Indy, but our recruiting has gotten better

DeekLyfter

6/11/21 12:05pm

My main concern is stepping back

Remigius

6/11/21 11:51am

Actual playoff access is a step forward. BBall would be a HUGE step forward.

Moops

6/11/21 11:58am

Nope.

All-American

6/11/21 11:55am

Do you actually believe BYU would be admitted as an At Large to a playoff?

Moops

6/11/21 11:56am

When in the Indy Era would BYU have won the AAC?

molodyets

6/11/21 12:00pm

I am an AAC fan as I follow Houston. BYU could have won and gone to an NY6 2020

Moops

6/11/21 12:02pm

Exactly. Byu hasn’t been shown they can win with an Indy schedule

cougfanz

6/11/21 12:02pm

Let’s assume they wouldn’t. They still shouldn’t give up independence.

All-American

6/11/21 12:23pm

If BYU wants to be the best house cat on the block it should step backward to G5

SLIVER

6/11/21 11:59am

What does BYU give up to join the AAC? What do they get?

JJCoug

6/11/21 12:21pm

The AAC will give BYU scheduling visibility around the country

BYU Fan

6/11/21 12:43pm

The key question is the crystal ball for the AAC - are they on a sustainable path or is this 2005-2010 MW hoops

molodyets

6/11/21 1:20pm

There will be no guaranteed access to the playoff for any G5 team.

Zastava

6/11/21 12:22pm

Uh, literally every source I've seen rumored says you are wrong.

Moops

6/11/21 12:29pm

My understanding is that the highest ranked G5 conference champ would receive...

Zastava

6/11/21 2:00pm

Ok, then we are on the same page. That said, the AAC has dominated that NY6 bid.

Moops

6/11/21 2:01pm

If Boise and SDSU left the MW it would be as bad of a league as the MAC and CUSA.

molodyets

6/11/21 2:03pm

You are the company you keep. I’d much rather play the USC’s, Stanford’s...

Zastava

6/11/21 2:16pm

So is BYU keeping company with UMass & Liberty or USC & Stanford?

BYU Fan

6/11/21 2:27pm

This is a great question considering we lost to UMASS a couple years ago

FieroCoug

6/11/21 3:17pm

We currently have the freedom to play (or not play) whomever we choose.

Zastava

6/11/21 3:40pm

So wrong. As a Houston fan, I can say, without any question, no Houston fan

Moops

6/11/21 3:43pm

Houston is a terrible school with a pathetic fan base.

Zastava

6/11/21 3:52pm

You are a peach. Its been fun, but I am done chatting.

Moops

6/11/21 3:53pm

Have you ever been to a houston game? Those fans and the experiences

FieroCoug

6/11/21 4:02pm

I’ve been to three Houston/BYU games. I despise that fan base almost...

Zastava

6/11/21 4:33pm

We've got 3 wins over you 🙂

molodyets

6/11/21 4:05pm

I believe Navy deliberately chose the AAC over Independence

BYU Fan

6/11/21 4:06pm

We only kinda get to play who we choose.

FieroCoug

6/11/21 3:45pm

That’s not true. We play Baylor, Washington State, Virginia and USC during...

Zastava

6/11/21 4:29pm

I agree with u... but seasons like last one revealed that the majority of fans

cougfanz

6/11/21 4:16pm

I don't trust the committee to ever let a G5 team get an at large bid.

JJCoug

6/11/21 2:29pm

BYU will very rarely need to worry about it.

Zastava

6/11/21 3:05pm

What fun is it playing the big boys if you have nothing to play for and lose

FieroCoug

6/11/21 3:19pm

If you can’t beat the big boys then you certainly don’t belong in the playoff.

Zastava

6/11/21 3:44pm

Obviously but at least in the AAC you could use a game or two and still

FieroCoug

6/11/21 3:47pm

The chances of the top ranked G5 champion having 2 losses is very slim.

Zastava

6/11/21 4:47pm

An undefeated indy BYU will never make the playoff. That's not as

FieroCoug

6/11/21 4:49pm

There’s no evidence to suggest that. A top 6 or 7 undefeated BYU team...

Zastava

6/11/21 4:54pm

Agreed. Just responding to your comment about taking your chances as an at large

JJCoug

6/11/21 3:20pm

We'd only be losing a couple P5 games a year and we'd have something to play for

FieroCoug

6/11/21 3:21pm

lol. no. we don't "keep" their money, NY6 access, bowl access, schedules,

Moops

6/11/21 2:35pm

I don’t think BYU is P5, but I DO think they are better than most of the AAC.

Zastava

6/11/21 2:49pm

That's ok so dont need people who turn their noses up to people

FieroCoug

6/11/21 4:04pm

I would rather have very little to do with them.

Zastava

6/11/21 4:36pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad