Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up
Jun 11, 2021
12:33:32pm
Dr T-bone All-American
I am a big fan of Independence. A more clear path to playoff is not enticing.
I love playing the big teams, playing a tough schedule, even if it results in 7 or 8 win seasons a lot of the time. The AAC is a decent conference with some teams I would like to play regularly but filled with half of teams that I would rather not play regularly. It is rare for BYU to be top G5/ Non-P5 - We certainly haven't been in the past decade, not once. Not sure I want to give up the great schedule and fun games we now have with independence in order to have a slighly better chance at a playoff birth once every 10-20 years. In my opinion the conference championship has the potential for cheapening things, allowing less deserving teams to make it into the playoff. If BYU makes it into the playoff, I want it to be on their own merits, not just because BYU wins the AAC championship in a down year where they probably don't deserve to be there. Earn it by playing top teams and going 11-1 or maybe 10-2.

I would love the system to go back to a computer based ranking system where people like Gary Barta are able to push their own agendas. Not sure that will happen, but something like a BCS type selection system would be much more fair.

My equation for preference remains the same:

P5>Independence>G5
Dr T-bone
Previous username
taylorgpierce
Bio page
Dr T-bone
Joined
Apr 3, 2011
Last login
Jun 19, 2021
Total posts
3,858 (305 FO)
Messages
Author
Time

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.