I say take the 2-3 great games from Hall if you can, then adapt. Play the best guy now.

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jun 14, 2021
5:06:50pm

Turnpike Lane Monday Morning Quarterback

I say take the 2-3 great games from Hall if you can, then adapt. Play the best guy now.

If he just gets through the Arizona, Utah and ASU games, I'll take it. Especially if can go 2-1.

Report problem with this ad

Turnpike Lane

Previous username: lawboy
Bio page: Turnpike Lane
Joined: Dec 14, 2004
Last login: Oct 15, 2023
Total posts: 124,282 (29,256 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Brief thoughts on Hall v Romney v Conover.

Penske Material

6/14/21 5:01pm

I say take the 2-3 great games from Hall if you can, then adapt. Play the best guy now.

6/14/21 5:06pm

I have the same concerns about Hall

2FarGone

6/14/21 5:09pm

We’d move to Romney who has already shown the ability to win games. We’d use that time to prep Conover just in case

6/14/21 5:14pm

Probably, but I have heard that the plan was to bring in Conover this year at some point regardless

2FarGone

6/14/21 5:18pm

Heard from who?

BigYfan

6/14/21 5:25pm

IIRC; Wilson came in because Mangum was underperforming

Powerbait DPM

6/15/21 6:18am

I don't understand why Romney gets constantly downgraded for that win over BSU.

Lance71

6/14/21 5:17pm

Agreed, and I meant to stress that he did execute well. But to say, as some

Penske Material

6/14/21 5:30pm

So, a good game manager. Good it. I agree.

6/14/21 5:34pm

Yes, which is more than BYU has had at QB before Wilson for a very long time.

Lance71

6/14/21 8:18pm

It could be argued Ty Detmer was a consummate game manager, mostly.

SinkingQuffa

6/14/21 9:52pm

RE: It could be argued Ty Detmer was a consummate game manager, mostly.

6/14/21 11:51pm

I think a lot of top programs roll their dice on the vice versa oftentimes.

SinkingQuffa

6/15/21 12:04am

<< Deleted >>

kudzucoug

6/15/21 7:30am

my quick (unpopular) thoughts

warp

6/14/21 5:30pm

The OL returns 6 guys have have started multiple games, so better than average.

6/14/21 5:37pm

When you say Conover was “highly” recruited

BigYfan

6/14/21 9:43pm

You could say the same about Wilson

wildeone

6/14/21 11:49pm

He was a Four Star

2FarGone

6/15/21 12:04am

For sure he was higher rated than Hall and Romney

BigYfan

6/15/21 5:59am

That Saban flew out to Arizona to offer him makes him as good as a 5* in my mind

SinkingQuffa

6/15/21 8:31am

That is the definition of hyperbole

BigYfan

6/15/21 10:12am

Not more hyperbolic than the things said about Hall

2FarGone

6/15/21 11:07am

Hyperbole? I drew a comparison I meant to be taken literally.

SinkingQuffa

6/15/21 11:13am

You said he was a 5 star in your mind simply because Saban offered him

BigYfan

6/15/21 5:29pm

Yeah. The winniest college HC of the biggest program in the country.

SinkingQuffa

6/15/21 5:43pm

And here are his offers: he was highly recruited (notice the four stars)

2FarGone

6/15/21 12:10am

I don't think that's unpopular at all.

Eddie

6/15/21 1:28pm

You play the best player regardless

kimdaddy35

6/14/21 5:34pm

Right. That nonsense about possible re-injury would have unfairly cut short a

Forzaitalia

6/14/21 7:36pm

The thing about Hall is that he started 2 games, and got a concussion in each

Dan

6/14/21 7:58pm

Isn't it possible that Hall never recovered fully from concussion #1 and was

Forzaitalia

6/14/21 8:50pm

But what a college career Austin Colley had. I would call him a

6/14/21 9:11pm

Yes. And Austin was afforded several chances to play in the NFL after worse con-

Forzaitalia

6/14/21 9:28pm

What if the best player is a freshman without college game experience?

2FarGone

6/15/21 12:08am

If he can perform consistently better against our 1st team defense when they are

kimdaddy35

6/15/21 10:32am

I agree

2FarGone

6/15/21 11:06am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad