It wouldn't surprise me if Utah has a stud QB winning conference awards and being talked about at the national level, while BYU ends up with a just OK placeholder.
It also wouldn't surprise me if BYU ends up with a stud and Utah has a black hole at the position that holds them back.
So much uncertainty means that either team could have the position be a plus, neutral or negative for them. And that's before even getting into the fact that both favorites (Hall and Brewer) have injury histories that complicate everything even more