They would need a College Football Redzone on steroids to watch all of the games. And even that doesn't really tell you all of the story.
BYU is evaluated the way on average most of the teams are evaluated. Some voters may watch the whole game. Some might catch parts. Some check the box score and game logs and probably read the recap.
They are never going to love our team as much as we do when we dominate, nor detest our team as much as we do when we win...but not to the satisfaction of some.
We should absolutely, undeniably be grateful that the voters don't share the masochistic need to devalue wins of some fans.
BYU would not have won the national championship in 1984 if voted on by a certain type of fan on this board.