And yet the arguments for and against BYU back then are the same arguments today

Report problem with this ad

Oct 21, 2021
8:03:31am

Goliath Truly Addicted User

for and against Cincinnati.

Report problem with this ad

Goliath

Previous username: Koolio
Bio page: Goliath
Joined: May 25, 2005
Last login: Apr 25, 2024
Total posts: 30,421 (1,759 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Cincinnati deserves the Playoffs. Their only loss in 2 years is to UGA by 3 pts

Goliath

10/21/21 7:48am

I don't know how what happened 35 years ago matters this season, but ok.

byubyu

10/21/21 7:50am

You can pretend you can't see any correlation between the arguments people made

Goliath

10/21/21 7:55am

It's a very different landscape than it was in 1984.

ReyOso

10/21/21 8:01am

And yet the arguments for and against BYU back then are the same arguments today

Goliath

10/21/21 8:03am

Minus the playoff.

Q-grr

10/21/21 8:42am

RE: It's a very different landscape than it was in 1984.

akbarishiwatsu

10/21/21 10:32am

Well one problem is you're comparing a top 1 argument to a top 4 argument

byubyu

10/21/21 8:14am

Agree--if they win out, they should be rewarded for the past two years, just

Shinshin

10/21/21 7:51am

Yes if they win out they should go. But college football is mostly a sham so they probably won’t

YIsForBrigham

10/21/21 7:54am

I think they're in if they win out

displacedute

10/21/21 7:55am

Then you believe Gary Barta will fail at his main job.

zsmooth

10/21/21 8:05am

I think the first set of rankings will tell us if they’re serious about Cincy

Gator

10/21/21 7:55am

Their Sagarin SOS is ranked 93rd in the country. So they need Notre Dame to win out

TCuz

10/21/21 7:56am

I see the argument about their SOS, but this is pretty much the same team that

Shinshin

10/21/21 7:59am

So the next best part about their resume is that a team from a different year lost to another team.

TCuz

10/21/21 8:02am

I guess. If you ignore the part about how they performed against that schedule

Goliath

10/21/21 8:08am

How they performed against that schedule is reflected in their Sagarin ranking. They are #5. Behind Bama/UGA/OSU/OU.

TCuz

10/21/21 8:11am

So, that sounds pretty darn good.

Goliath

10/21/21 8:15am

That's why looking beyond simply "strength of schedule" and seeing how they

Goliath

10/21/21 8:00am

Looking at previous years also benefits Bama, UGA, OSU, OU. The exact teams ahead of them.

TCuz

10/21/21 8:09am

It should definitely be considered. Shouldn't be given priority over this years

Goliath

10/21/21 8:19am

They've been accepted in the cartel so the cartel may let them join the playoff

vagabonder

10/21/21 7:59am

They’re not gonna let the AAC have all that $$ this year just cause Cincy is moving to the cartel later.

zsmooth

10/21/21 8:06am

Ash tray money for the Cartel. NBD.

grosven

10/21/21 9:31am

Never happening

troutmaster13

10/21/21 8:04am

Their SOS is bad, very bad

2FarGone

10/21/21 8:05am

I want to see them in the playoff. I hope they win out

Adrielle

10/21/21 8:06am

No one who matters really cares who deserves to be in, that’s not their goal.

StalwartBraveTrue

10/21/21 8:12am

Weird that the G5 members of that committee are just good to go with the conspiracy!

TCuz

10/21/21 8:17am

Hair Thompson and the AD from Arkansas state? They’re supposed to have a

StalwartBraveTrue

10/21/21 8:23am

They deserve to be in the playoff simply to beat GA in 3OT in NC game #SECShorts

(Private)

10/21/21 8:36am

UCF had two years with ZERO losses going into the playoff selection

krindorr

10/21/21 8:41am

Nowhere did I hint that this was a prediction. I said it is what they deserve

Goliath

10/21/21 8:47am

We're in agreement there

krindorr

10/21/21 9:33am

thumbs up they deserve, thumbs down, don't trash 84!

Tuskaloosa Cougar

10/21/21 8:53am

I'm not trashing '84. Just pointing out that you can't trash Cincy without

Goliath

10/21/21 9:26am

oh im just having fun. I agree!

Tuskaloosa Cougar

10/21/21 9:38am

The biggest difference between 1984 and now isn't what you think

krindorr

10/21/21 10:52am

Hard to argue but shows how easy it is to play that schedule - still gotta

truecougster

10/21/21 10:37am

Cincy is good, but their QB has a shady look to him. Not a fan.

SJS

10/21/21 10:38am

their profile is definitely more deserving than 1984 BYU

Hill4Heisman

10/21/21 11:19am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad