My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Dec 7, 2021
6:47
:04
pm
coldcoug
Truly Addicted User
An independent BYU was not qualified for NY6.
We know the rules, we chose to not be in a conf. Championship and we almost made it on rankings but we lost twice. There ya go.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
coldcoug
New username
outsidethebubble
Bio page
coldcoug
Joined
Dec 1, 2010
Last login
Dec 17, 2021
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Is Herbstreit all right??? Glad he was able to get that off his chest… I’m sure
TempeCoug
12/7/21 6:11pm
Twitter reveals so much stupidity that I wish I wasn't aware of.
SingleStrapBackpack
12/7/21 6:12pm
He should come check out CB, and he'll hear plenty . . .
Shinshin
12/7/21 6:13pm
Well, when your employer owns all broadcasting rights, you’ve got to squash
1984coug
12/7/21 6:13pm
All the while, an independent BYU is kept out of the NY6 in favor of...
Little Mac
12/7/21 6:15pm
An independent BYU was not qualified for NY6.
coldcoug
12/7/21 6:47pm
Ummm. That's my point. ND got one. BYU was more qualified than some...and at
Little Mac
12/7/21 6:56pm
They didn’t need to elevate them Utah/Pitt at 14/15 still would have gotten in
PHXSUNS31
12/7/21 6:59pm
Yes. Exactly. You're highlighting my point. Under the current system...
Little Mac
12/7/21 7:14pm
Fair, just didn’t know if your issue was with the committee or the whole system
PHXSUNS31
12/7/21 7:17pm
Noytre Dame had a better record (11-1). Pitt and Utah were conference champs.
coldcoug
12/7/21 7:22pm
Not just realizing it. It's just being highlighted this year more starkly.
Little Mac
12/7/21 7:30pm
Such a loser.
byubyu
12/7/21 6:15pm
Tim Brando's reply:
Manti
12/7/21 6:16pm
I can only think of 2 teams G5 that had strong arguments to be in the CFP
NYC and Japan
12/7/21 9:25pm
I would think he is including the BCS years. Before the playoffs small schools
ColonelMustard
12/8/21 9:31am
BCS era there were only 2 teams selected, not 4. G5 teams rarely approach top 2
NYC and Japan
12/8/21 3:41pm
And all it took was two perfect seasons!
durandal
12/7/21 6:16pm
And luckily they had a good ND on the schedule this year.
swingcat
12/7/21 6:36pm
Just my take, but ND is not good or proven
LateToTheGame
12/7/21 7:02pm
UCF right now:
OPINIONS
12/7/21 6:16pm
Seriously though. 2 years undefeated.
letthewookieewin
12/7/21 6:17pm
Did someone remind him of the red-headed stepchild that is BYU?
idacoug
12/7/21 6:16pm
That seem uncharacteristic of the guy. Random meltdown.
Backcountry
12/7/21 6:17pm
Yeah, this feels really weird.
Music
12/7/21 6:22pm
Sheesh that was salty. Uncharacteristic of him. Chill Herbstreit. It’s a cartel.
BlooCoog
12/7/21 6:18pm
Only in because they happened to play ND and ND ended up not losing again
Deleted
12/7/21 6:18pm
Yup if ND's loss was to anyone else they would have the #4 spot
Kajdin
12/7/21 6:20pm
Bingo. Was a perfect storm this year that FORCED the committee to let them in
boorad
12/7/21 6:23pm
I'm not sure why all the g5s don't do it.
SCcoug
12/7/21 6:21pm
You have cracked the nut. Now we have the formula. 😉
Happy As Larry
12/7/21 8:00pm
This guy perfectly lays out what it takes to get into the CFP. P5 vs G5
Schultz is back
12/7/21 6:28pm
It is rigged. That’s how it’s built. Even after BYU gets in the B12 it will still be rigged.
Turnpike Lane
12/7/21 6:29pm
Have they accepted a 12 game playoff
germ1
12/7/21 6:48pm
Yes but still debating over how to determine the auto bids.
Turnpike Lane
12/7/21 6:52pm
I thought after the last meeting someone said an 8 team playoff was still in
Schultz is back
12/7/21 7:15pm
OK State would have jumped Cincinnati if they had won
Charles Darwin
12/7/21 6:33pm
100%
VACOUGFAN
12/7/21 8:34pm
Well, he’s right that the people who said it would never happen were wrong.
DieHarder
12/7/21 6:37pm
"Conspiracy" implies that things are being done in secret. All of the P5 CFP bias has been plainly in the open the
SingleStrapBackpack
12/7/21 6:50pm
It's out in the open and everyone knows it, but the CFP still pays lips service
Schultz is back
12/7/21 7:23pm
Right. I'm just commenting on the fact that it's ridiculous for Herbie to be calling people conspiracy theorists for
SingleStrapBackpack
12/7/21 7:25pm
LOL. Michigan started the season unranked and lost a game and still finished…
ChadFromCougarTown
12/7/21 6:44pm
Michigan played and beat good teams. Truth is, most G5 teams play 2-3
PHXSUNS31
12/7/21 7:05pm
Isn’t that kind of the point?
ChadFromCougarTown
12/7/21 7:07pm
I’m not exactly sure what you mean here
PHXSUNS31
12/7/21 7:18pm
Right but it’s the team not the schedule. UCF got jobbed. Cinci didn’t luckily. Emphasis on luckily.
Turnpike Lane
12/7/21 7:09pm
I don’t remember the details around UCF, did they beat anyone good those years?
PHXSUNS31
12/7/21 7:16pm
The problem is that perfection doesn't guarantee jack squat. Cincinnati had to go undefeated for 2 years straight, get
SingleStrapBackpack
12/7/21 7:32pm
I don’t disagree with anything you say, just gotta hope for an expanded playoff
PHXSUNS31
12/8/21 5:27am
*perfect twice
DiamondMo
12/7/21 8:02pm
This chick nails it with her response
ColonelMustard
12/7/21 7:11pm
I like Kirk but he goes down a lot of notches for me if this is how he feels
ColonelMustard
12/7/21 7:13pm
So he is basically saying that 90% of the time the system sucks and gets it
boctabulous
12/7/21 7:15pm
How many losses does the 1st place seed have again? Sit down Herb.
AltTabbins
12/7/21 7:21pm
What a joke Herbie has become. I used to really like him
gurt
12/7/21 10:19pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad