...come in and immediately challenge Hall, and would clearly be better than Conover.

I honestly have no idea how good he would or would not be. I'd love to have him on the team simply because the coaches want him - and if they do then I do too. But this idea that every time another relatively high recruit comes along they are going to put BYU over the top and be clearly better than everyone else on the roster, with the assumption they'll win the starting job like it isn't debatable - that's all just silly to me.