Weren’t in the books. I think what he did with the stuff that was actually in the books was pretty good-it just was brought down by too much extra crap that wasn’t in them. And Alfred especially. WORST. CHARACTER. EVER! He adds nothing important and is just the scummiest of the scummy people. His character is useless. Useless and irritating. The kind of person that deserves to be slapped just for existing 😂 I mean even Jar Jar is a better character (though I like him, the general consensus is he is a bad character)