It felt almost automatic for the opponent. I'd be interested to see how our 3rd and long defensive stats compare

Report problem with this ad

Jun 22, 2022
12:14:13pm

IdahoCoug A.I. Expert

to the rest of the country.

Report problem with this ad

IdahoCoug

Bio page: IdahoCoug
Joined: Mar 14, 2001
Last login: May 28, 2023
Total posts: 10,816 (359 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

FWIW, Tuiaki said they did a lot of analytical research on things which actually matter with defensive play

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

6/22/22 11:46am

1st insight: Tackle guy with ball

braddahmike

6/22/22 11:48am

Preventing big plays is the primary goal of the system because those hurt you more than anything else.

molodyets

6/22/22 11:48am

He's got a point but you gotta stop the other team on downs as well.

Kajdin

6/22/22 11:49am

yep. and we struggle on that. against weak teams

Y'zGuy

6/22/22 11:51am

The biggest problem last year, by far, was giving up almost 5 yards a run on first down

Indy Coug

6/22/22 11:51am

I just remember dreading 3rd and long

AF Cougar

6/22/22 12:07pm

It felt almost automatic for the opponent. I'd be interested to see how our 3rd and long defensive stats compare

IdahoCoug

6/22/22 12:14pm

I just looked up our stats for opponent's 3rd down conversion. So not 3rd and long, per se, but still relevant.

IdahoCoug

6/22/22 12:24pm

We were 109th in opponents' 4th down conversion rate.

IdahoCoug

6/22/22 12:26pm

BYU was 106th at 43%

Indy Coug

6/22/22 12:31pm

The stats I looked up didn't include FCS opponents, only games involving two FBS teams

IdahoCoug

6/22/22 3:00pm

This is a good example of why looking at stats as N/130 doesn't tell you much. We had 194 3rd downs last year (maybe

molodyets

6/22/22 12:39pm

114th out of 130 isn't very good, right?

boctabulous

6/22/22 5:31pm

And I look at 3rd and long as a VERY big play. Them converting on 3rd and long

viper

6/22/22 12:16pm

Gotta stop the run on first down, that's the most important rule of defense 101.

Mitty

6/22/22 12:25pm

Tuiaki did say stopping the run was a top priority

Dr T-bone

6/22/22 2:56pm

Seems like I've heard that many times before. Kind of like when we hear them say

ManicBlue

6/22/22 5:11pm

BYU opponents gained 5 or more yards on 1st Down 46.6% of the time in 2021. That was up from 34.3% in 2020 & 42.1% in 19

Spiff

6/22/22 4:59pm

I think that's an interesting conversation - I honestly don't know the answer.

Eddie

6/22/22 11:53am

Giving up a long play (especially a score) is an outlier of offensive performance, so you are in effect spotting them 7

molodyets

6/22/22 11:55am

Team with more points per play (explosiveness) wins 71% of the time:

molodyets

6/22/22 12:01pm

Are there teams that don't try and prevent big plays?

Coug

6/22/22 11:55am

RE: Preventing big plays is the primary goal of the system because those hurt

Heath Squashwell

6/22/22 11:55am

Or just limiting the number of points scored. That doesn't factor in time of

cougaman

6/22/22 12:13pm

Three words.... Coastal Caro Lina.

RealityCheck

6/22/22 12:25pm

Five Words? Ala Bama Bir Ming Ham

Happy As Larry

6/22/22 2:35pm

Was he saying it is research since the end of last season, or in general? Because if it's stuff he's learned over his

IdahoCoug

6/22/22 11:51am

Whatever side you’re on regarding Tuiaki and his D the following is true:

Beggar

6/22/22 11:51am

and sadly I don't have confidence in Kalani to fix the problem

Y'zGuy

6/22/22 11:57am

That’s the other issue. Kalani has been willing to make other changes. Just not

Beggar

6/22/22 12:02pm

RE: FWIW, Tuiaki said they did a lot of analytical research on things which

oryguncoug

6/22/22 11:52am

This is amazing... Sitake, Lamb, Clune and now Tuiaki... former DC's and current DC experience...

Coug

6/22/22 11:53am

The plan of the defense is a failing one.

kimdaddy35

6/22/22 11:55am

It is the defense Sitake wants. That won’t change with the coordinator unless he

Charles Darwin

6/22/22 11:57am

Not according to Sitake's own mouth.

kimdaddy35

6/22/22 11:59am

I will trust his actions over how some fan took his words

Charles Darwin

6/22/22 12:00pm

In other words you don't pay attention. I figured based on your comments.

kimdaddy35

6/22/22 12:16pm

I wouldn’t make a habit of putting what is said in PR situations ahead of what

Charles Darwin

6/22/22 12:21pm

21-4. If there was a big reason to change they'd do it.

Blueto

6/22/22 12:00pm

LOL. ah the 21-4 drum shows up

Y'zGuy

6/22/22 12:02pm

Defense didn't lose the CC game. Offense went nowhere and turned it over all

Blueto

6/22/22 12:05pm

and yet 2 more min of possession wins us the game

Y'zGuy

6/22/22 12:07pm

Huh? How? TOP doesn't equal points.

GSwarriorcoug

6/22/22 8:13pm

Good point. It's good to be reminded of data.

Happy As Larry

6/22/22 2:40pm

Now do the first 3 games of 2021 when the D was healthy. Cherry-picking the

Abe Froman

6/22/22 12:11pm

This is the worst argument of all. Who got hurt? Pili? He caused the change? No if you go back you see we played

kimdaddy35

6/22/22 12:21pm

LOL not as bad as “Kalani wanted to win that one”. Come on.

Abe Froman

6/22/22 12:33pm

sitake only wants to win certain games.

Belboz

6/22/22 2:48pm

Yes no coach has ever put more effort into one game over another....oh wait.

kimdaddy35

6/22/22 4:07pm

That sounds like a bad idea to me.

Belboz

6/22/22 5:22pm

You seem to struggle understanding what you read.

kimdaddy35

6/22/22 6:17pm

I was kidding. I'm sure Sitake wants to win every game

Belboz

6/22/22 9:14pm

Thinking a coach might be more involved in game planning in the off-season for a certain big game doesn't seem

kimdaddy35

6/22/22 4:07pm

losing games upsets coaches and fans. Win all of them.

Belboz

6/22/22 5:22pm

Thinking injuries don’t matter, but Kalani wanting to win a given game does, is

Abe Froman

6/22/22 7:07pm

Who said Kalani didn't want to win games? Oh that was you. I agree peak foolishness.

kimdaddy35

6/22/22 8:28pm

Read again - that isn’t what I said. Keep ignoring the early games that refute

Abe Froman

6/22/22 8:38pm

You mean Utah? That's the game.

kimdaddy35

6/22/22 8:41pm

Sure thing

Y'zGuy

6/22/22 12:21pm

Ah the old “Time of Possession” drum shows up, and it can’t even explain the

Abe Froman

6/22/22 12:32pm

lets look at the BYU vs Utah TOP....

Y'zGuy

6/22/22 2:29pm

Points per possession is the important metric

rad dawg

6/22/22 2:37pm

time of possession is meaningless.

molodyets

6/22/22 2:58pm

can't score if you dont have the ball

Y'zGuy

6/22/22 3:24pm

You get the same number of chances as the other team (at most 1 possession difference)

molodyets

6/22/22 3:49pm

Explain your time of possession obsession to this guy

Blueto

6/22/22 12:41pm

Ahh.... the decision to cry about 21-4 and completely disregarding it for things which haven't happened yet

Indy Coug

6/22/22 12:39pm

'19 Toledo, '19 USF, '20 CC, and '21 UAB games had similar feels

Doogal McCougar

6/22/22 12:20pm

The plan isn't the issue. We saw that with the first 4 games last year.

Gorgias

6/22/22 12:08pm

Recruiting and development, but let's not put any blame on him because he just

cougaman

6/22/22 12:16pm

Very few teams outside the SEC could compete with that many key injuries.

rad dawg

6/22/22 12:24pm

More excuses.

cougaman

6/22/22 6:01pm

I didn't hear anything that lead me to believe that the research was just done this year. That is CB echo chamber.

PJMort

6/22/22 11:56am

But 3 former and 1 current DC can't figure out the issues?

Coug

6/22/22 11:56am

They didn't do analytics to see "what was wrong". They wanted affirmation of the things to focus the most.

Indy Coug

6/22/22 11:56am

Perhaps we should consider that they are not all clueless but think they are

Charles Darwin

6/22/22 11:57am

Nah. People here know much better.

Blueto

6/22/22 11:59am

Seriously. Have we stooped to Yelp level on CB?

kiyoshige

6/22/22 6:36pm

You sound like the old-school baseball scouts in Moneyball.

Gorgias

6/22/22 11:59am

That's an amazing interpretation, anyway. CB FTW!

Abe Froman

6/22/22 12:00pm

Every team in college football does this.

rad dawg

6/22/22 12:01pm

Sometimes humans are more receptive to change when a little more objective

BringYourUltimate

6/22/22 5:39pm

We can hope

RUNBYU1

6/22/22 5:48pm

I'm totally buying his explanation of playing "aggressive coverages" as opposed

BGRTHNUMEGO

6/22/22 11:54am

Drives of 18 plays or more are very rare in CFB, so we've decided to focus our defense

Disco Lemonade

6/22/22 11:57am

Not 18, but 12-play 7 minute drives seem to happen pretty regularly vs BYU

Kajdin

6/22/22 12:00pm

The non-garbage-time national average for plays per drive is 5.71. Last year we avg 6.28. The difference between top 10

molodyets

6/22/22 12:28pm

Also, national average time off the clock - 144 seconds vs 163. 20 seconds of playing time. However that's not adjusted

molodyets

6/22/22 12:29pm

The problem is other teams aren't so stupid to continually give the other team short passes and open runs. So

kimdaddy35

6/22/22 12:03pm

It’s sad that

I'mBatman

6/22/22 12:05pm

Research says to basically never punt. Why are we still punting? Why is anyone

Iman23

6/22/22 12:05pm

For one, that research essentially assumes that the Law of Large Numbers will bail you out in the long run

Indy Coug

6/22/22 12:24pm

It doesn't say never punt. They have a table of when to punt and when not to.

Genghis Spreads

6/22/22 12:28pm

They forgot to look into the actual playing of defense, however.

Mitty

6/22/22 12:23pm

Well geez that makes me feel better. If there's one guy that can take a look at

byubyu

6/22/22 12:36pm

I was pleasantly surprised the variety of defensive play calling against 1st 3 PAC12 teams. Then USF

CLCougar

6/22/22 1:13pm

Recruit better on defense? Specifically d-line and linebacker.

legiaourbana

6/22/22 2:15pm

What's Tuiaki's take on the "things that actually matter"?

Posting on CougarBoard