Any list that is topped by, as you said, a “routine field goal” as the all-time top play, is a dumb list.

Report problem with this ad

Jun 24, 2022
1:18:53pm

mvtoro Scrub

You need better criteria.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jun 24, 2022 at 1:18:53pm

Message modified by mvtoro on Jun 24, 2022 at 1:20:03pm

Message modified by mvtoro on Jun 24, 2022 at 1:20:19pm

Report problem with this ad

mvtoro

Bio page: mvtoro
Joined: Nov 28, 2006
Last login: Apr 25, 2024
Total posts: 11,556 (753 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Where does everyone rank the Tyler Allgeier punch-out in BYU’s all time top plays? I place it 5th.

Yllage Vidiot Humbly Awesome

6/23/22 7:45pm

Somewhere in 30 to 40 range

Bumpus Hound

6/23/22 7:47pm

And I would put Kyle Morrell's leap over the line as #2 all time

Bumpus Hound

6/23/22 7:52pm

<< Deleted >>

CarolinaCoug

6/23/22 7:56pm

How is Mangum Miracle even top ten?

fulano

6/23/22 8:03pm

We beat Nebraska at their place on a true Hail Mary. Freshman QB just back from his mission thrown into game d/t injury

Yllage Vidiot

6/23/22 8:09pm

You can count on one hand the number of actual hail mary last play of the game

Y05

6/23/22 8:25pm

It would be interesting to come up with an actual list of true “Hail Mary’s”, ie last sec long (> 30 yds?) game winners

Yllage Vidiot

6/23/22 8:35pm

You dropped Bosco to Smith for the National Championship????

Tare

6/23/22 8:03pm

Yep. Good play but not top 10 IMO. I went for wow factor of the play itself I guess.

Yllage Vidiot

6/23/22 8:06pm

I like for "wow factor" to get greater emphasis on a top plays list.

Y05

6/23/22 8:22pm

Significance of situation has to play into it. For example, if we kicked a routine 30 yard fg as time expired to win a

thewaterboy

6/23/22 8:31pm

I guess it depends on what each of us means when we say “top” play

Yllage Vidiot

6/23/22 8:41pm

You are talking “most significant”/“historically impactful”, not “best individual effort” top plays, I think.

Yllage Vidiot

6/23/22 9:18pm

No way. Then we should just go down the list of most important games and cite final plays of consequence regardless of

mvtoro

6/23/22 9:29pm

That would be a dumb list. Good thing that's not what I said.

thewaterboy

6/24/22 5:08am

Any list that is topped by, as you said, a “routine field goal” as the all-time top play, is a dumb list.

mvtoro

6/24/22 1:18pm

Answer: About #50. Maybe. It was cool but overall impact was low compared to

BleedCougarBlue2

6/24/22 12:11am

Agree to disagree. Most impactful play I’ve seen in a long time. How was the “overall impact low”? I don’t understand.

Yllage Vidiot

6/24/22 4:26am

Kyle Morrell's play is #2 - not just because it was an incredible play, but

Posting on CougarBoard