Sep 26, 2022
9:18:30am
9:18:30am
What do the rules say on the phantom fumble rumble play?
16:55 on the snaptotackle video.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBPd6VSMTUQ
Obvious incomplete pass. refs let the play develop because none of them had line of sight to the turf bounce. fine. I think they made the right call in letting the play develop. After the incomplete pass, there was a BYU penalty during the return. A blocking penalty that never would have happened had they blown the play dead appropriately.
Seems like you either give BYU the Turnover AND the penalty, or you give them neither. How do you assess a penalty for a called back play? The incomplete was a 2nd and goal at the 9. This should have brought up 3rd and 9. Instead of an incomplete pass, Wyoming gets a possible INT reversed, a 15 yard penalty bonus, and a 1st down, and they get it at the 4 yard line. Because refs didn't blow the play dead. They scored on the next play.
With the calm of Monday morning quarterbacking, what is the correct call?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBPd6VSMTUQ
Obvious incomplete pass. refs let the play develop because none of them had line of sight to the turf bounce. fine. I think they made the right call in letting the play develop. After the incomplete pass, there was a BYU penalty during the return. A blocking penalty that never would have happened had they blown the play dead appropriately.
Seems like you either give BYU the Turnover AND the penalty, or you give them neither. How do you assess a penalty for a called back play? The incomplete was a 2nd and goal at the 9. This should have brought up 3rd and 9. Instead of an incomplete pass, Wyoming gets a possible INT reversed, a 15 yard penalty bonus, and a 1st down, and they get it at the 4 yard line. Because refs didn't blow the play dead. They scored on the next play.
With the calm of Monday morning quarterbacking, what is the correct call?
- Previous username
- BigWoodThunder
- Bio page
- Cougarclaw
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2011
- Last login
- Apr 23, 2024
- Total posts
- 59,453 (14,872 FO)
Looking at this play a couple times, we should've gotten called on something. (Mostlyaccurate, Sep 26, 2022 at 9:43am)
Messages
Time
9/26/22 9:21am
9/26/22 9:22am
They made the correct call, but it was completely incompetent of them to not recognize that it was an incomplete pass
9/26/22 9:22am
9/26/22 9:27am