No. He was ok the first 3 years but his scheme has been bad and did not attract

Jan 23, 2023
10:49:42am

Idacoug All-American

Recruits.

I still think Kalani should have been fired for that debacle…..to just watch it happen over the years with no accountability and putting cousin before program.

Report problem with this ad

Idacoug

Bio page: Idacoug
Joined: Mar 30, 2001
Last login: Apr 18, 2024
Total posts: 53,576 (353 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

It would sure be nice if the football staff got the same support as Pope.

FieroCoug

1/23/23 10:14am

Two things here

Indy Coug

1/23/23 10:16am

Also, kalani had a bad year when he's supposed to have a good year.

Mostlyaccurate

1/23/23 12:52pm

We literally won more games than most predicted. CB is the only place

FieroCoug

1/23/23 1:46pm

Well...FB staff had 6 or 7 years of patience esp at DC

Tmoney1969

1/23/23 10:17am

Until 2020 the same thing could have been said of the football staff.

cougarfann888

1/23/23 10:18am

Kalani made progress from his 2nd year to 3rd year. Then he was average for a

FieroCoug

1/23/23 10:34am

I've learned in the last year that BYU fans are not ready for BYU to be in the Big12.

kccougar

1/23/23 10:22am

This year he has had his first RM's return from their missions. If Hall,

BYUheaven

1/23/23 10:23am

it is harder to have a cohesive offense when you insert a lot of new blood every

LeonMarek

1/23/23 10:27am

Umm…Kalani and nepotism with his cousin that harbored an atrocious defense

Idacoug

1/23/23 10:25am

The defense was average or close to average until this year.

FieroCoug

1/23/23 10:30am

No. He was ok the first 3 years but his scheme has been bad and did not attract

Idacoug

1/23/23 10:49am

Lol it wasn’t a big debacle worth firing him over. Ironically after those first

FieroCoug

1/23/23 11:04am

Yes it was. He put his cousin over byu football program. Knowing he sucked.

Idacoug

1/23/23 11:08am

Yet in those years he went 29-9.

FieroCoug

1/23/23 11:12am

And set back byu recruitment on defense

Idacoug

1/23/23 11:16am

Yet still won games….

FieroCoug

1/23/23 11:17am

29-9 isn’t “great.” By any measure.

lightmann

1/23/23 1:07pm

By BYU standards against those schedules it is. Our previous best season

FieroCoug

1/23/23 1:51pm

A 3 year average of 10-3 (well, 9.7-3) is better than Detmer's 3 seasons as a full time starter.

Indy Coug

1/23/23 2:40pm

IMO - for BYU, 2 losses or less in a season is what I'd call "great." 3 loss seasons I might call semi-great if there

lightmann

1/24/23 1:00pm

For 1 season I agree but for a 3 year stretch, the consistency is more

FieroCoug

1/24/23 1:12pm

We had a terrific offense. Defense, not so much.

84 natlchamps

1/23/23 1:19pm

Kalani and Tuiaki aren't cousins (eye roll) ...your credibility is taking a hit

Das_Countach

1/23/23 11:15am

🤦‍♂️ you apparently do not understand the Polynesian culture.

Idacoug

1/23/23 11:17am

And you’re probably a white dude from Idaho trying to fit in with poly culture

FieroCoug

1/23/23 11:18am

Not from Idaho. Just went to school there. I have many poly friends

Idacoug

1/23/23 11:57am

your credibility is further taking a hit with that comment

Das_Countach

1/23/23 11:18am

RE: your credibility is further taking a hit with that comment

Das_Countach

1/23/23 11:23am

I have no credibility. This is a bleeping sports message board. It’s all about

Idacoug

1/23/23 11:59am

Right. Tom Holmoe and President Worthen are all about nepotism and would 100% allow it under their watch.

TheLoneCougar

1/23/23 12:56pm

The expectations were low for this team from the outset

CaliWG

1/23/23 10:30am

We've seen them play well at times - including most of the Gonzaga game - and

LV Mike

1/23/23 11:26am

The football staff has been allowed to stick around a lot longer than any power

SaintJeff

1/23/23 11:59am

John Wooden was 19-12 his 4th year at UCLA. I wonder why they stuck with him

Tygercoug

1/23/23 12:22pm

I’m not saying whether I think pope is the guy or not cause I don’t know.

FieroCoug

1/23/23 12:42pm

Early in the season the fire Pope crowd was beginning to make noise.

lightmann

1/23/23 1:03pm

Plenty of people have said they want Pope gone. Pope has never gone 4-9 or come close.

kimdaddy35

1/23/23 1:24pm

2 years NCAA tourney as 6 seed, 1 year NIT. This year is the worst season the

jreid191

1/23/23 3:33pm

Tuiaki is gone. Get over It.

BYUlv

1/23/23 5:12pm

I’m glad tuiaki is gone. I’m talking about kalani. Even the day after tuiaki

FieroCoug

1/23/23 5:16pm

Okay. I thought that you were just expressing some bitterness over the way CBers

Posting on CougarBoard