Hope he's a great player for us. Couldn't care less about star ratings. All

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 24, 2023
10:38:10am

Adwight All-American

Hope he's a great player for us. Couldn't care less about star ratings. All

that matters is what you do on the field. We've had way too many "highly rated" recruits pan out to exactly nothing.

Report problem with this ad

Adwight

Previous username: tebowned
Bio page: Adwight
Joined: Apr 4, 2009
Last login: Apr 17, 2024
Total posts: 10,983 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Heckard gets that 4 ⭐️ rating

1/24/23 10:13am

So we're going all in with their ability to rate transfers? BYU is up to 33rd in the transfer portal rankings

Indy Coug

1/24/23 10:14am

Well, since they rated him high, yes.

1/24/23 10:15am

This is the way

rcbyufan

1/24/23 10:23am

Way more college tape to rate transfers

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

1/24/23 10:33am

And they still haven't even rated Fitzgerald. He's gotta be a 3-star.

mjmill

1/24/23 10:38am

Bagnah, Lapuaho, and Cravens don’t count towards transfer ratings yet either

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

1/24/23 11:00am

The amount of data makes it much easier to evaluate accurately

1/24/23 10:38am

Curious if that #33 rating is just for players transferring in, or if it also

StantonMac

1/24/23 10:54am

They still miss on their fair share.

slatecoug

1/24/23 11:07am

guy seems like a real baller... so happy he chose us...

HarlemCoug

1/24/23 10:16am

You know what this reminds me of? NFL free agency

Big12Yfan

1/24/23 10:22am

BYU made it out just in time.

kccougar

1/24/23 10:29am

Where are all the dudes complaining about getting an FCS DB?

Mjolnir

1/24/23 10:37am

I did initially. I'll eat that crow if he balls out in 2023.

1/24/23 10:38am

Lol hes an nfl prospect.

1/24/23 2:00pm

So was Kaleb Hayes going into 2022, so we'll see what happens.

1/24/23 3:13pm

Hope he's a great player for us. Couldn't care less about star ratings. All

Adwight

1/24/23 10:38am

When BYU gets a committed athlete to get a 4th star AFTER they commit

1/24/23 10:39am

Not until they actually do anything worthwhile on the field. I think of guys

Adwight

1/24/23 11:31am

A couple things. 4*+ athletes overwhelmingly contribute more on the field

1/24/23 11:44am

The better recruiting ranking wins 75% of games. We already overachieve.

FieroCoug

1/24/23 12:54pm

Cool info, but I think Slovis should be a 4* for sure. Underrated

AntiSNOT

1/24/23 10:39am

When you consider that Keenan Pili was given a 4 star rating, I'd Slovis should also have received a 4 star rating.

slatecoug

1/24/23 11:33am

Slovis is essentially a 4*. 3* ranges from 79-89.5- Slovis is 89, so as close..

Das_Countach

1/24/23 1:02pm

But, but . . . our two 4 stars are not from P4 programs.

CrimWalCoug

1/24/23 10:41am

Are we now caring about transfer ratings?

kimdaddy35

1/24/23 3:11pm

They affect class ranking overall, so yeah. And you are concerned about recruits

1/24/23 3:15pm

I love recruiting. Transfer portal guys are not the same. For one everyone already knows who they are. For another, they

kimdaddy35

1/24/23 3:34pm

When you evaluate an incoming HS class do you subtract the graduating seniors?

kccougar

1/24/23 3:50pm

Transfer Portal is the new recruiting. Prob more accurate ratings, less misses

Das_Countach

1/24/23 3:58pm

Heck are came out of High School in 2017 as a 2*

Stalwartbob

1/24/23 4:16pm

So was the Saints emerging Star Shaheed...who also qas an obvious nflbyalent at

1/24/23 4:41pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad