Seems to me that’s exactly how it works.

Jan 24, 2023
11:01:21am

StantonMac Monkey see monkey do

The team is only as good as the players, and 13 out that averaged 3 stars seems to be an overall loss compared to 9 in that average 2.5 stars.

Report problem with this ad

StantonMac

Bio page: StantonMac
Joined: Mar 2, 2001
Last login: Nov 28, 2023
Total posts: 31,125 (2,582 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU is killing it in the transfer portal

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

Jan 24, 10:07am

Do you mind showing what they were previously

ordinary tri guy

Jan 24, 10:11am

RE: Do you mind showing what they were previously

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

Jan 24, 10:38am

Awesome...that ks for pulling this

ordinary tri guy

Jan 24, 11:19am

You need to do their updated transfer ratings.

uteman13

Jan 24, 10:39pm

Who does these ratings? How does Conover get an 86?

Stalwartbob

Jan 25, 4:22pm

I agree. 247 Sports has a team that does transfer ratings. I will say an 86 is

uteman13

Jan 25, 4:38pm

Those are at key positions too. Great job, BYU.

Genghis Spreads

Jan 24, 10:19am

9 Players transferred to BYU - 13 Players transferred from BYU. 23 Stars in 39

byucougarsbig12

Jan 24, 10:26am

Good thing that’s not how it works lol

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

Jan 24, 10:33am

I can't wait to hear how it works, please?

byucougarsbig12

Jan 24, 10:36am

Here is how it works, when Players transfer from BYU to northern Colorado

travelcoug

Jan 24, 12:02pm

Translation: Only bad players transfer out and only good players transfer in.

ochobeeguy

Jan 24, 1:23pm

Did I say that? Your seer stones are low on batteries

travelcoug

Jan 24, 1:26pm

The clown response is including Holker as your crown jewel of bad players.

ochobeeguy

Jan 24, 1:46pm

Holker's mid

CougtheCreator

Jan 24, 1:59pm

This is a bad take.

davidmj10

Jan 24, 3:40pm

His stats are mid, athleticism mid, makes sense he ended up at CSU.

CougtheCreator

Jan 24, 3:50pm

Trying, or lack of, was his problem.

Jeffacka

Jan 24, 5:00pm

I never said bad. Not good enough to be #1 isn’t bad so you go to a place where

travelcoug

Jan 24, 2:13pm

If Holker was good he wouldnt have ended up at CSU

Backcountry

Jan 24, 4:57pm

I agree. We got better quality coming in.

ChandlerAZCoug

Jan 24, 6:12pm

Your view of how it works is pretty odd.

LifeLongLakerFan

Jan 24, 12:27pm

Hans Olson today said he knows 3 local kids who were told a school wasn’t

Armchaircoug

Jan 24, 3:21pm

Seems to me that’s exactly how it works.

StantonMac

Jan 24, 11:01am

Except some of those stars are positive attrition

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

Jan 24, 11:11am

You're assuming every incoming player will contribute and discounting some

byucougarsbig12

Jan 24, 11:16am

That’s fair, we won’t know for sure until next season

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

Jan 24, 11:37am

Brooks struggled?

RGGeemer

Jan 24, 12:20pm

He kinda did to start the season

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

Jan 24, 12:36pm

Most think Arod struggled, not understanding how to utilize Brooks.

Les IsMore

Jan 24, 8:34pm

3 of the guys mentioned in your OP are one-year guys.

StantonMac

Jan 24, 11:29am

Is this still true in the portal era?

tacallaway

Jan 24, 2:12pm

The only guarantee you've got is the one year of a grad transfer. Everyone else

Kajdin

Jan 24, 3:44pm

Are the 23 & 39 stars the "re-rankings", or is one/both of those their HS rating

Best Guess

Jan 24, 11:16am

I’d love a WR, two LB and a safety rated in that vicinity to be really excited

Big12Yfan

Jan 24, 10:28am

There is still time.

antiyewt

Jan 24, 8:06pm

And those in the portal now can commit at any time.

Soupie

Jan 24, 9:12pm

They’ve done well to fill some needs

I'mBatman

Jan 24, 10:34am

Agree 💯

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

Jan 24, 10:35am

Quality 👍 but quantity is meh at best for B12

Lombardi

Jan 24, 11:07am

Its gonna take 3-4 more classes. No one gets quality depth in 1 class.

Turnpike Lane

Jan 24, 11:22am

USC (and Colorado?) would like a word

NYC and Japan

Jan 24, 11:37am

U$C and Dion Sanders... Great comparison for BYU...

The_Cuss

Jan 24, 11:48am

Uh, maybe CU can get more than 1 win in a season first? Lol

mulletino

Jan 24, 4:08pm

USC lost to Utah 2x, and lack of depth at QB and other positions is why.

Turnpike Lane

Jan 24, 11:52am

USC must have improved depth to go form 4-8 to 11-1 in a year. Every team has

NYC and Japan

Jan 24, 1:03pm

USC’s defense wanted a word.

davidmj10

Jan 24, 12:51pm

They dont/won't have quality depth

fattycoug

Jan 24, 4:15pm

We took a lot of hits too. Probably a net negative.

BlueNtheFace

Jan 24, 12:22pm

RE: We took a lot of hits too. Probably a net negative.

Moto2001

Jan 24, 2:15pm

Having a hard time losing some of our more promising players:

BlueNtheFace

Jan 24, 3:39pm

You have to have some pretty pessimistic goggles on to think that it has been a

Rise Against

Jan 24, 6:32pm

I think you're minimizing the losses and maximizing the gains

StantonMac

Jan 30, 6:01pm

According to 247 and their team ranking process, outgoing transfers do not

uteman13

Jan 24, 11:24pm

. . . you left out the most impressive transfer of all: Jake Retzlaff

fruitless

Jan 24, 3:10pm

He's not a transfer. He's considered a recruit because he came from a JC.

Rise Against

Jan 24, 6:17pm

That's a bold prediction, why do you think he'll beat out Slovis?

antiyewt

Jan 24, 8:14pm

Slovis had one good year at USC and it's been pretty mediocre since . . . .

fruitless

Jan 25, 2:13pm

As long as you are so excited about ratings, Slovis is the 25th rated QB

Stalwartbob

Jan 24, 4:21pm

Better news, 247 has rated 20th

Stalwartbob

Jan 24, 9:11pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad