I never said bad. Not good enough to be #1 isn’t bad so you go to a place where

Jan 24, 2023
2:13:08pm

travelcoug All-American

You are good enough and the competition int be as stiff.

He wasn’t bad, he was good. I liked him. He wasn’t good enough to accept the role that his current skill set dictated. At csu he won’t have to worry about that

Report problem with this ad

travelcoug

Bio page: travelcoug
Joined: Aug 21, 2005
Last login: Apr 25, 2024
Total posts: 24,639 (2,713 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU is killing it in the transfer portal

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

1/24/23 10:07am

Do you mind showing what they were previously

ordinary tri guy

1/24/23 10:11am

RE: Do you mind showing what they were previously

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

1/24/23 10:38am

Awesome...that ks for pulling this

ordinary tri guy

1/24/23 11:19am

You need to do their updated transfer ratings.

uteman13

1/24/23 10:39pm

Who does these ratings? How does Conover get an 86?

Stalwartbob

1/25/23 4:22pm

I agree. 247 Sports has a team that does transfer ratings. I will say an 86 is

uteman13

1/25/23 4:38pm

Those are at key positions too. Great job, BYU.

Genghis Spreads

1/24/23 10:19am

9 Players transferred to BYU - 13 Players transferred from BYU. 23 Stars in 39

byucougarsbig12

1/24/23 10:26am

Good thing that’s not how it works lol

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

1/24/23 10:33am

I can't wait to hear how it works, please?

byucougarsbig12

1/24/23 10:36am

Here is how it works, when Players transfer from BYU to northern Colorado

travelcoug

1/24/23 12:02pm

Translation: Only bad players transfer out and only good players transfer in.

ochobeeguy

1/24/23 1:23pm

Did I say that? Your seer stones are low on batteries

travelcoug

1/24/23 1:26pm

The clown response is including Holker as your crown jewel of bad players.

ochobeeguy

1/24/23 1:46pm

Holker's mid

CougtheCreator

1/24/23 1:59pm

This is a bad take.

davidmj10

1/24/23 3:40pm

His stats are mid, athleticism mid, makes sense he ended up at CSU.

CougtheCreator

1/24/23 3:50pm

Trying, or lack of, was his problem.

Jeffacka

1/24/23 5:00pm

I never said bad. Not good enough to be #1 isn’t bad so you go to a place where

travelcoug

1/24/23 2:13pm

If Holker was good he wouldnt have ended up at CSU

Backcountry

1/24/23 4:57pm

I agree. We got better quality coming in.

ChandlerAZCoug

1/24/23 6:12pm

Your view of how it works is pretty odd.

LifeLongLakerFan

1/24/23 12:27pm

Hans Olson today said he knows 3 local kids who were told a school wasn’t

Armchaircoug

1/24/23 3:21pm

Seems to me that’s exactly how it works.

StantonMac

1/24/23 11:01am

Except some of those stars are positive attrition

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

1/24/23 11:11am

You're assuming every incoming player will contribute and discounting some

byucougarsbig12

1/24/23 11:16am

That’s fair, we won’t know for sure until next season

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

1/24/23 11:37am

Brooks struggled?

RGGeemer

1/24/23 12:20pm

He kinda did to start the season

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

1/24/23 12:36pm

Most think Arod struggled, not understanding how to utilize Brooks.

Les IsMore

1/24/23 8:34pm

3 of the guys mentioned in your OP are one-year guys.

StantonMac

1/24/23 11:29am

Is this still true in the portal era?

tacallaway

1/24/23 2:12pm

The only guarantee you've got is the one year of a grad transfer. Everyone else

Kajdin

1/24/23 3:44pm

Are the 23 & 39 stars the "re-rankings", or is one/both of those their HS rating

Best Guess

1/24/23 11:16am

I’d love a WR, two LB and a safety rated in that vicinity to be really excited

Big12Yfan

1/24/23 10:28am

There is still time.

antiyewt

1/24/23 8:06pm

And those in the portal now can commit at any time.

Soupie

1/24/23 9:12pm

They’ve done well to fill some needs

I'mBatman

1/24/23 10:34am

Agree 💯

Ghost Pirate LeChuck

1/24/23 10:35am

Quality 👍 but quantity is meh at best for B12

Lombardi

1/24/23 11:07am

Its gonna take 3-4 more classes. No one gets quality depth in 1 class.

Turnpike Lane

1/24/23 11:22am

USC (and Colorado?) would like a word

NYC and Japan

1/24/23 11:37am

U$C and Dion Sanders... Great comparison for BYU...

The_Cuss

1/24/23 11:48am

Uh, maybe CU can get more than 1 win in a season first? Lol

mulletino

1/24/23 4:08pm

USC lost to Utah 2x, and lack of depth at QB and other positions is why.

Turnpike Lane

1/24/23 11:52am

USC must have improved depth to go form 4-8 to 11-1 in a year. Every team has

NYC and Japan

1/24/23 1:03pm

USC’s defense wanted a word.

davidmj10

1/24/23 12:51pm

They dont/won't have quality depth

fattycoug

1/24/23 4:15pm

We took a lot of hits too. Probably a net negative.

BlueNtheFace

1/24/23 12:22pm

RE: We took a lot of hits too. Probably a net negative.

Moto2001

1/24/23 2:15pm

Having a hard time losing some of our more promising players:

BlueNtheFace

1/24/23 3:39pm

You have to have some pretty pessimistic goggles on to think that it has been a

Rise Against

1/24/23 6:32pm

I think you're minimizing the losses and maximizing the gains

StantonMac

1/30/23 6:01pm

According to 247 and their team ranking process, outgoing transfers do not

uteman13

1/24/23 11:24pm

. . . you left out the most impressive transfer of all: Jake Retzlaff

fruitless

1/24/23 3:10pm

He's not a transfer. He's considered a recruit because he came from a JC.

Rise Against

1/24/23 6:17pm

That's a bold prediction, why do you think he'll beat out Slovis?

antiyewt

1/24/23 8:14pm

Slovis had one good year at USC and it's been pretty mediocre since . . . .

fruitless

1/25/23 2:13pm

As long as you are so excited about ratings, Slovis is the 25th rated QB

Stalwartbob

1/24/23 4:21pm

Better news, 247 has rated 20th

Stalwartbob

1/24/23 9:11pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad