What makes you so confident? They’ve been good the last 5 years but they’re

Jan 31, 2023
2:53:07pm

Polemic All-American

Still pretty average in total value that they could bring to the Big 12, especially considering that they wouldn’t bring in a new TV market. It would almost make more sense for the big 12 to just let Utah die on the vine and let their current member BYU become the lone big dog in the state

Report problem with this ad

Polemic

Previous username: Food Snob
New username: Lord Jim
Bio page: Polemic
Joined: Mar 25, 2013
Last login: Feb 16, 2023
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

ASU is upset according to Flugaur and Monty

runningryan Pretend Athletic Director

1/31/23 1:57pm

Why would they be upset? Because George is entertaining unequal distribution to Oregon and Washington?

YIsForBrigham

1/31/23 1:58pm

Or they've been led on by George that they are in a good situation and they're

CameronG

1/31/23 2:00pm

Welcome to the Big 12 ASU and U of A

CameronG

1/31/23 1:59pm

I think Big12 only takes 2 out of the 4 "four corner schools"

CougarCanuck76

1/31/23 2:00pm

Four corner nonsense is a media creation. It isn’t based in reporting

travelcoug

1/31/23 2:02pm

UU and CU are both arrogant. UU doesn't want to go to BYU's conference

Dangerous

1/31/23 2:00pm

My message to Utah and CU

runningryan

1/31/23 2:01pm

My Message

Cougar TD

1/31/23 2:09pm

RE: My Message

ZWOOKIEZyoutube

1/31/23 5:20pm

RE: My Message

BluesBrother

1/31/23 7:40pm

Mine:

Resurgens

1/31/23 8:04pm

Nah...Utah likes the association with the P10 academics. As a fan, I'd prefer the P12 right now because Utah has an

TFL

1/31/23 2:26pm

Utah has to prove they can beat a P5 program that's not in the PAC before talking about being top 3-4 in the Big 12.

slatecoug

1/31/23 3:03pm

Pac-12 champion Utah just got thumped by BIG 10 3rd place team Penn State.

Gentleman Stan

1/31/23 3:11pm

Lol. So Utah doesn't go to the Big 12 because they lost to Penn State and to Florida? So due to this ugly on the

TFL

1/31/23 3:37pm

No they don't go because no one wants them

YIsForBrigham

1/31/23 3:43pm

It's not based upon one single game. It's that they are not additive. Utah would dilute, not add.

slatecoug

1/31/23 4:04pm

There's that UU education shining through

AlternateShot

1/31/23 5:47pm

Let it be so, I hope Utah stays there forever. We both agree lol. And your joke

The_Cuss

1/31/23 5:05pm

What non-PAC games have the Yewts won lately? Their the top of a trash league.

CharlottesvilleCoug

1/31/23 6:51pm

Can Swaim confirm?

BYUheaven

1/31/23 2:00pm

Which is kind of ironic

byukarl

1/31/23 2:00pm

If everyone was happy, they would have signed a deal yesterday.

Art Director

1/31/23 2:01pm

Yes, but I think ASU was the hold up on Arizona

runningryan

1/31/23 2:02pm

It does seem Arizona wanted big 12 but were ruluctant to leave without ASU. So

johnnybyu

1/31/23 2:11pm

UU is stupid, but I don't think they're that stupid. I still think they end up..

Team Chaos

1/31/23 2:02pm

Probably so, but I hope they have to wait 5 years and have lots of uncertainty till it happens

runningryan

1/31/23 2:03pm

make it 10

CrashMcLarson

1/31/23 2:18pm

Why would the Big 12 take Utah when they already have that market and already

CameronG

1/31/23 2:03pm

They aren’t fist second third fourth fifth sixth and maybe seventh

travelcoug

1/31/23 2:08pm

Close but the order is

runningryan

1/31/23 2:13pm

My guess is Utah admin thinks BYU will wage the battle for them when needed.

panacablue

1/31/23 2:06pm

I really hope BYU doesn't wage that battle for them

CameronG

1/31/23 2:08pm

This better not occur.

Tmoney1969

1/31/23 2:13pm

I really hope the BYU admin takes to heart the recent story of Utah bragging

Corn Pop

1/31/23 2:14pm

Dr Crow is not one to piss off…

ChandlerAZCoug

1/31/23 3:28pm

Wouldn't that piss him off?

sah22

1/31/23 7:42pm

Getting a Sellout when they play BYU at Home. Will make him happy.

ChandlerAZCoug

1/31/23 11:03pm

RE: My guess is Utah admin thinks BYU will wage the battle for them when needed.

El Careeb

1/31/23 2:17pm

Utes don't need any help. They're a shoo in for the Big 12 if they want it.

TFL

1/31/23 2:27pm

What makes you so confident? They’ve been good the last 5 years but they’re

Polemic

1/31/23 2:53pm

Is it ignorance, myopia, or both?

slatecoug

1/31/23 3:08pm

Neither. It's the reality of CFB today and the goals of the Big 12 in the next go around. I get this sense from around

TFL

1/31/23 4:49pm

Thanks for the laugh, but once again, Utah is not additive. All Utah would do is dilute the per school payout.

slatecoug

1/31/23 11:02pm

What is it with Ute fans and these delusional views of national relevance?

Ursas Puma

1/31/23 3:23pm

Probably more of the opposite. BYU fans' approach to Utah is to constantly

TFL

1/31/23 5:03pm

Keep on begging...it's actually kind of fun to watch the logical pretzels you

AlternateShot

1/31/23 5:53pm

Okay, so you actually believe it all. Thanks for answering that question.

Ursas Puma

1/31/23 6:13pm

Your AD seems to think Utah is the biggest brand in the conference

machete

1/31/23 6:49pm

It’s a delusional take from extreme Ute fans that lurk on CB. Hopefully it’s not

The_Cuss

1/31/23 5:08pm

I'm going to go with "trolls"

AlternateShot

1/31/23 5:51pm

Doesn't line up with Yormarks remarks on further expansion candidates

machete

1/31/23 3:50pm

Good point. While I agree with TFL the Utes are a shoo in, I'm not sure anyone

kiyoshige

1/31/23 5:05pm

What exactly did he say? Didn't he say national recognition? Sorry, but outside Oregon and UW...no one else left offers

TFL

1/31/23 7:49pm

RE: What exactly did he say? Didn't he say national recognition? Sorry, but

machete

1/31/23 8:37pm

So defiantly no Utah

ExitStageLeft

1/31/23 8:54pm

Definitely not the shoo in that some here think

machete

1/31/23 9:02pm

So this wasn't his quote?

TFL

1/31/23 9:02pm

That quote is in no way contradictory to the other one

machete

1/31/23 9:12pm

BYU fans who think the Big 12 will pass up on Utah, just because...is a silly ideal to cling to

TFL

2/1/23 9:01pm

So, the opposite of what the big 12 commish is saying

Mitty

1/31/23 5:51pm

RE: Utes don't need any help. They're a shoo in for the Big 12 if they want it.

zonacougar

1/31/23 7:28pm

How unwise is Utah? They're so bad, they flipped a virgin to the dark side.

akbarishiwatsu

1/31/23 2:48pm

You realize you just compared the Utes to virgins …

BluesBrother

1/31/23 7:42pm

What is a money perch? Some kind of big fish at ASU?

Florwood

1/31/23 2:16pm

Utah's playing it right. They may as well wait out the P12. They can jump to B12 any time. BIG is out of the picture for

TFL

1/31/23 2:22pm

Jump to the Big 12 any time eh?

CougtheCreator

1/31/23 2:25pm

And there's the arrogance.

Corn Pop

1/31/23 2:27pm

This is what Utah fans tell themselves but it's not true. The pecking order is surely Oregon/Washington > ASU/Arizona

YIsForBrigham

1/31/23 2:28pm

UW and Oregon are great but they're not going to commit long term and they don't like the Big 12.

TFL

1/31/23 3:34pm

You're basing it all on on-field performance. Which adds bring in the most money

CougtheCreator

1/31/23 3:35pm

Not really. Fan attendance, TV ratings, recruiting, NFL, prestige, sustainability of success. Phx and Denver are greater

TFL

1/31/23 6:26pm

We will see. Oregon and Washington are not going to be let behind in some conference with Wyoming and Boise St

YIsForBrigham

1/31/23 3:44pm

There is a very good chance that OR never gets invited to the B10

Nat Gas Man

1/31/23 3:45pm

Wouldn't be surprised if they go independent rather than join big12 tbh

machete

1/31/23 3:56pm

That is really hard and the CFP would be worse

Nat Gas Man

1/31/23 4:02pm

Need more bottom feeder/train wreck types and Pac12 has alot of those

machete

1/31/23 3:54pm

I tend to think the pecking order for joining the B12 is Oregon/Washington ->

kos

1/31/23 3:53pm

Utes are the third guy in this video

travelcoug

1/31/23 2:33pm

That's gotta hurt!

AlternateShot

1/31/23 5:57pm

They waited...and they saw. Yesterday the PAC 10 or 12 showed that it can't

Doogal McCougar

1/31/23 2:48pm

I'll take Myopic Fans for $200 Alex

slatecoug

1/31/23 3:06pm

I’d vote them down purely on a financial basis. They bring nothing

Bluedomination

1/31/23 3:12pm

Also taking utah handicaps BYU, why not have one great utah team over two

CougtheCreator

1/31/23 3:20pm

This is the way.

The_Cuss

1/31/23 5:10pm

The ACC is your problem

runningryan

1/31/23 3:13pm

This is exactly correct. B12 would like AZ

BlueTooth

1/31/23 3:52pm

Yup, this is true and TFL has no answer for it. Self awareness is lacking.

The_Cuss

1/31/23 5:10pm

Umm...yeah...if the ACC was going to break the GOR it would've happened. When your entire theory relies on something

TFL

1/31/23 7:41pm

Let me help you out TFL

runningryan

1/31/23 10:02pm

I don't follow. So what ACC schools are going to add more than $100 million per year to the BIG

TFL

2/1/23 2:00am

What you are missing is ACC media revenues are relatively flat through 2035 while

runningryan

2/1/23 10:35am

But what's the threat? that's 10 years away

TFL

2/1/23 11:48am

How's the weather in Egypt this time of year?

machete

2/1/23 12:42pm

It's a super fun discussion. The heart of it is that

TFL

2/1/23 1:46pm

Respectfully, I wish you'd stop saying this - that Utah is the only realistic

kos

2/1/23 3:10pm

Utah doesn't provide the Pacific Time Zone and is in a market already occupied

CameronG

2/1/23 3:35pm

Exactly

The_Cuss

2/1/23 8:27pm

Yup, I agree.

The_Cuss

2/1/23 8:27pm

I appreciate the point but I think you're all going to be very surprised if the P10 falls apart

TFL

2/1/23 9:04pm

What does Utah bring that the Big 12 doesn't already have or doesn't have a better option with another school?

slatecoug

2/3/23 8:33am

Current 2-time P5 champ. Winningest and most consistently ranked P12/B12 team in CFP era. Highest

TFL

2/3/23 10:50am

You just listed all on-field accomplishments

CameronG

2/3/23 12:20pm

Nope. Every round is different. The moves for large markets and high profile schools are ahead of contract

TFL

2/3/23 12:30pm

Yeah...nobody else has any fans. Only the yewts. They are the reason anyone at

AlternateShot

2/3/23 12:53pm

This is the biggest mistake BYU fans make. In the west, it's not about the fanbase

TFL

2/3/23 1:18pm

You clearly don't pay any attention to the viewership numbers when Utah is the biggest name in the matchup.

slatecoug

2/3/23 2:59pm

Nah...BYU fans stuck into these awkward paradigms about fanbase and viewership

TFL

2/3/23 3:29pm

Wasting your breath. He's incapable of understanding that concept.

AlternateShot

2/3/23 12:51pm

Its a waste of time... TFL thinks PAC12 wins > media market $. #Utebusinesslogic

The_Cuss

2/3/23 2:38pm

According to your logic, Boise St. should have been invited. Why weren't they?

slatecoug

2/3/23 3:00pm

And why would a bad USC and UCLA join the B1G? Why is SDSU mentioned as well?

The_Cuss

2/3/23 3:05pm

A bad USC?

slatecoug

2/6/23 1:13am

Any team taken from P10 moves needle compared to P10 ‘cause they are down a team

ZWOOKIEZyoutube

2/1/23 3:17pm

Here's the crux...you think expansion is about increasing competitiveness.

AlternateShot

2/1/23 3:44pm

Is seriously doubt OSU and WSU would be invited to the B12

Nat Gas Man

2/1/23 3:56pm

Getting Washington, Oregon, ASU, and Zona

runningryan

2/1/23 4:39pm

Nailed it.

The_Cuss

2/1/23 8:27pm

If Utah losing to UF, Penn State and tOSU is a deal killer...lol...lol...wait until you see what the other Pac-12

TFL

2/1/23 9:33pm

If ASU and Arizona jumped, UU and CU would too. There is no way they put

darkcoug

1/31/23 2:26pm

Have to wonder what UO and UW do if ASU and Zona jump. Go indy?

Corn Pop

1/31/23 2:29pm

That would be funny to watch. They would probably beg the big 12 for inclusion

johnnybyu

1/31/23 2:32pm

They only get in by signing the GOR. If faced with that or the indy wilderness,

Corn Pop

1/31/23 2:44pm

They may, they will have very little power is UofA or ASU jumpt first

johnnybyu

1/31/23 3:07pm

And if the only way UW and Oregon can come is to bring their little sisters,

AlternateShot

1/31/23 6:07pm

They'd join the Big12

YIsForBrigham

1/31/23 2:45pm

Hopefully ASU and UoA burn their house down and we get to see what happens.

Dryfire

1/31/23 8:55pm

That assumes there is spot for those teams...

Baylorbears11

1/31/23 2:38pm

I completely agree with you.

kos

1/31/23 3:55pm

Agreed. Good take. The 4 schools must think that Oregon and UW jumping them toward the Big 12

TFL

1/31/23 7:46pm

Oregon and Washington would be accretive to the Big 12 and would likely increase the TV value slightly

runningryan

1/31/23 10:14pm

I would also add, why would you dilute your payout by adding SMU to get into Texas when you can join the Big 12 and get

runningryan

1/31/23 10:17pm

Good question. Are you talking Oregon and UW?

TFL

2/1/23 11:10pm

Where would they jump to?

CougarCanuck76

1/31/23 2:46pm

Why would you add CU and UofU if Oregon and UW are still out there?

slatecoug

1/31/23 3:10pm

If Washington and Oregon stay in PAC 10 they will want more money. This will make some schools very unhappy...especially

coot20

1/31/23 2:33pm

All I want for Christmas is for this to be true

YOHONOMOTO

1/31/23 2:33pm

Same, now that I live in PHX

Sacto Cougar

1/31/23 5:53pm

Just curious about all these schools wanting to come to the Big 12? Maybe the

Bullrider

1/31/23 2:51pm

delusional and arrogant…deadly combination

icecougar

1/31/23 3:00pm

Ideal scenario, leave the pukes in the wilting P8

jtm0001

1/31/23 3:18pm

Michael Crow is not the guy to upset in the PAC. He holds a lot of power now

Nat Gas Man

1/31/23 3:26pm

It's hard for me to believe that the leaders of these unis are that stupid

ocmyhome

1/31/23 3:31pm

Kliavkoff has much to clean up after the mess Scott left in the PAC12. Tough job

Forzaitalia

1/31/23 3:35pm

Sorry bro but this take is nothing but inflammatory guesses…

rmarkerm

1/31/23 4:56pm

People expressing opinions and predictions on a message board? I would never have imagined!

runningryan

2/1/23 12:00am

And yes, University Presidents can be extremely naive and clueless.

runningryan

2/1/23 12:09am

Apparently more than a little upset. The tier 1 games were going to be sold to

Nat Gas Man

1/31/23 7:56pm

I think Oregon, Washington, ASU, and Arizona would all be accretive to the Big 12

Posting on CougarBoard