Sad that only one guy on that list had NBA success.

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jun 8, 2023
8:08:43pm

Tare All-American

Sad that only one guy on that list had NBA success.

Report problem with this ad

Tare

Previous username: Texas Hold'em
Bio page: Tare
Joined: Aug 8, 2002
Last login: Apr 25, 2024
Total posts: 20,079 (554 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

10 years later and this is still the list. Is that right?

AF Cougar

6/8/23 7:36pm

same top 5

g$

6/8/23 7:42pm

I swapped Jimmer and Ainge as well. I would also consider Cosic as #2. But

AF Cougar

6/8/23 8:00pm

Jimmer was aided by a better supporting cast than Cosic had.

SinkingQuffa

6/8/23 8:28pm

I think I swap Mike Smith for Bradley and then…

icecougar

6/9/23 3:11am

Jimmer #3. Bradley don't belong. Not close. He was very impactful as a Frosh.

SinkingQuffa

6/8/23 7:42pm

Who do you replace Bradley with instead?

Schultz is back

6/8/23 7:51pm

A lot of very good players over the years. In the last 10 years: Tyler, KC & Yo.

SinkingQuffa

6/8/23 7:53pm

Tyler Haws has more points than Jimmer. More complete player. IMHO

jlhazlewood

6/8/23 7:57pm

If he didn't come back from the mish in all-conf form — frankly, we woulda

SinkingQuffa

6/8/23 8:02pm

0.Are you talking Jackson Emery? Thought he was underrated.

jlhazlewood

6/8/23 8:14pm

No. Jax was a top-10 all-time defensive player, maybe. But not all-around, imo.

SinkingQuffa

6/8/23 8:16pm

Tyler more complete than Jimmer? Hmmm…

icecougar

6/9/23 3:00am

Mike Smith.

byubyu

6/8/23 7:57pm

Timo Saaralinan?

Brigham

6/8/23 7:58pm

Michael Smith, Mel Hutchins, or Dick Nemelka

UCLACoug

6/8/23 8:01pm

Fred Roberts is another potential option

AF Cougar

6/8/23 8:02pm

Maybe replace Bradley with another Center who was a McDonald's All-American and won 2 NBA rings?

Greg Kite's 'stache

6/8/23 8:33pm

And a killer stache

Tare

6/8/23 8:40pm

Vanilla Thunder

AF Cougar

6/8/23 8:45pm

An upperclassman Kite woulda stonewalled a Frosh Bradley well outside the paint

SinkingQuffa

6/8/23 8:49pm

Agreed that Ainge should be #1 over Jimmer.

mobomanjoe

6/8/23 7:53pm

Bradley was very impactful on a very talented team for a SINGLE year.

SinkingQuffa

6/8/23 7:58pm

Swap Ainge and Jimmer. Remove Bradley and replace with Tyler. But many others

WallaX2

6/8/23 8:07pm

Sad that only one guy on that list had NBA success.

Tare

6/8/23 8:08pm

What do you consider NBA success?

coug10278

6/8/23 8:52pm

While I see your point, Bradley had a very decent NBA career. One you would hope from a #2 pick? No. But far from the

6/8/23 9:07pm

I love Shawn Bradley, but the guys who were greater AT BYU than him include Mike Smith, Lee Cummard, Fred Roberts,

6/8/23 8:09pm

The great Jim Eakins

AF Cougar

6/8/23 8:10pm

And Craig Raymond

Oldcougfan

6/8/23 10:34pm

I would personally put Travis Hansen above Shawn Bradley

ElkhunterUT

6/8/23 8:11pm

Here is the answer: Ainge, Fredette, Cosic, Durant, and Smith.

BYUCPA

6/8/23 9:19pm

We have a winner! Perfect top 5.

Coug-Ida

6/8/23 10:05pm

Bill Walton has seen them all and played against Cosic. He says Kresimir Cosic is #1.

roseyscenario

6/8/23 9:29pm

But if you are the sports media looking to maximize subscriber count, pick Jimmer/Ainge #s 1 &2.

roseyscenario

6/8/23 9:42pm

Any list that doesn’t include Mel Hutchins is wrong

Bill

6/9/23 6:46am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad