when Jimmer wasn't the headline at BYU. If you recall, that was only 2 of his 4 years. Rose has steadily advanced the program every year. I don't expect him to win the tournament every year. What program wins their post season tourney every year.
If you want to compare post season tourney records, your going to have to do it on some other basis than just pure wins and losses. Some of the major conferences do it like the NIT. The higher seeded team gets a home game. Contrast that to the MWC, where no matter what happens, you play on UNLV's home court.
Most conferences aren't that stupid. Not even the little ol' WWC. If you noticed their conference brackets, they are set up to give the advantage to their highest ranked teams. It is in the best interest of the conference and earned throughout the year.