No. Same thing. Fan-fic is not a "child", bastard or otherwise, of the original.

Nov 30, 2012
7:42:27pm

spoxjox

Stephenie Meyer can be held responsible for her own works of fiction, but to blame her in any way for the pornography that others produce in their perverted "fan-fic" is completely beyond the pale.

Report problem with this ad

spoxjox

Bio page: spoxjox
Joined: Apr 5, 2011
Last login: Apr 19, 2024
Total posts: 22,651 (1,657 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: If you found a copy of "50 Shades of Grey" in your house, you would...

IGlowInTheDark

11/30/12 1:04pm

Be impressed.

Ashtrash

11/30/12 1:06pm

lose respect for whoever bought that garbage.

JohnnyD

11/30/12 1:12pm

The Trifecta of Suckiness - offensive, poorly written, and the spawn of Twilight

Ashtrash

11/30/12 1:14pm

Don't blame Twilight for that pornography.

spoxjox

11/30/12 1:17pm

It literally began as Twilight "fan fiction"

Ashtrash

11/30/12 1:19pm

Bull crap. Unless you want to say that Parker and Stone's drek is the spawn of

spoxjox

11/30/12 1:21pm

It's true, actually. The author of 50SoG originally wrote it with the characters

byujacob

11/30/12 1:26pm

I understand that. But that doesn't make the porn "Twilight"'s spawn.

spoxjox

11/30/12 1:27pm

Sure it does. Spawn = offspring.

byujacob

11/30/12 1:30pm

Then the "Book of Mormon" Broadway play was spawned by the Book of Mormon?

spoxjox

11/30/12 2:56pm

Spawn as in influenced by and exists because of - SURELY the answer is YES

BYU-Texas

11/30/12 7:11pm

That's not what "spawn" means, any more than you're the spawn of Haun's Mill.

spoxjox

11/30/12 7:34pm

Would you prefer love-child?

BYU-Texas

11/30/12 7:36pm

No. Same thing. Fan-fic is not a "child", bastard or otherwise, of the original.

spoxjox

11/30/12 7:42pm

Why do you assume those of us who call 50 the spawn of Twilight

byujacob

12/1/12 12:30am

I don't assume your meaning. I read your words.

spoxjox

12/1/12 7:55am

Btw, the analogies are hilarious.

spoxjox

11/30/12 1:34pm

Is twilight considered Mormon Theology?

WhiteKnight

11/30/12 1:29pm

So 50 Shades of Gray isn't spawned from Twilight, but Twighlight IS spawned

Illegal Jimmergrant

11/30/12 1:33pm

Dude-It was LITERALLY about Bella & Edward. It was INTENDED to be about

Ashtrash

11/30/12 1:50pm

So if I write a porn novel about Nephi, does that make it the spawn of the Book

spoxjox

11/30/12 1:56pm

You must be a SERIOUS Twilight fan.

IGlowInTheDark

11/30/12 2:37pm

"Oh, no! Someone thinks I'm a Twilight fan!" Moron.

spoxjox

11/30/12 2:56pm

feel bad because clearly I'm lacking.

Mayor of Cougartown

11/30/12 1:23pm

My mom works at a bookstore. Whenever someone asks for it, she just shivers

Posting on CougarBoard