The stars would really have to align in this scenario

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 3, 2017
2:02:27pm

mcnasty Contributor

The stars would really have to align in this scenario

Report problem with this ad

mcnasty

Bio page: mcnasty
Joined: Mar 20, 2006
Last login: Jun 10, 2024
Total posts: 1,673 (220 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

2017 RM and transfer list

donnerstag

1/3/17 9:53am

+Gabe Reid on the watch list

1/3/17 9:56am

Who was the guy that ended up at Michagan St the same time Reid went to Stanford

BYUHgrad

1/3/17 1:09pm

Mufi Hunt

donnerstag

1/3/17 1:52pm

Was he a mission bound guy, and is now back on the roster?

BYUHgrad

1/3/17 2:01pm

He didn't go

donnerstag

1/3/17 2:05pm

He went

tcherrin

1/3/17 2:22pm

How is he looking at MSU? Must not have played this year.

BYUHgrad

1/3/17 8:25pm

He redshirted

donnerstag

1/3/17 8:39pm

He wasn't even out a month including the MTC

donnerstag

1/3/17 8:36pm

The ratio of potential high-impact guys to destined depth guys seems . . .

Coop

1/3/17 10:56am

Folau will probably play for the yewts. Don't ask me how I know.

Swickit

1/3/17 12:13pm

A lot of other people in the know are saying he's a BYU lock. FYI.

Bostonblue

1/3/17 1:43pm

Yep

Swickit

1/3/17 2:19pm

If Sedgwick is one I'm thinking of, I believe he will be a good one.

silentvelcro

1/3/17 12:21pm

yup. He'll be very good.

Cougarclaw

1/3/17 1:49pm

He's a stud. Excited for him.

roarcougar84

1/3/17 8:08pm

It seems that Kalani will be able to get about 8 more 3 star guys each year. Replacing eight, two-star guys with that

HarlemCoug

1/3/17 12:23pm

This is a high level analysis

MHOP

1/3/17 12:24pm

The stars would really have to align in this scenario

mcnasty

1/3/17 2:02pm

Currently, 11 of our 19 commits have 2-stars. None have 4.

1/3/17 3:16pm

need to consider incoming transfers too. We're getting 3 star guys to transfer in...

HarlemCoug

1/3/17 3:54pm

That's fine, but it tough to say how much has to do with "recruiting" and how

1/3/17 4:59pm

compare the number of post missions flips from year to year and I think you'll see Kalani is getting more of them

HarlemCoug

1/3/17 5:58pm

That's a short-term thing

BYU'01

1/3/17 7:22pm

A lot of DL's there. Good.

lightmann

1/3/17 12:37pm

Vaka is the guy we need.

macaroni

1/3/17 1:17pm

just to clarify - Vaka is a guy we already got....

HarlemCoug

1/3/17 1:17pm

right. i'm just saying that we need him now. biggest need, imo.

macaroni

1/3/17 1:18pm

Hopefully by some miracle he can play this coming season..

1/3/17 1:58pm

won't take a miracle at all. He's going to be available for spring ball and

Bostonblue

1/3/17 2:02pm

Oh, I think I'm thinking of Kirby. Vaka is JC isn't he, so eligible immediately?

1/3/17 2:25pm

yep

Bostonblue

1/3/17 2:47pm

Awesome. That is great for the OL then

1/3/17 2:56pm

Can you update with the season listed that they are expected to be on roster?

Katewot

1/3/17 2:14pm

They are almost all freshmen

donnerstag

1/3/17 2:17pm

It's the transfers I'm wondering about. Who has to sit, who doesn't?

Katewot

1/3/17 2:20pm

Kirby and Tukuafu will have to sit

donnerstag

1/3/17 2:25pm

Tukuafu shouldn't have to sit. He just isn't eligible for a scholarship. He

cougaman

1/3/17 3:02pm

Kirby might not have to sit either... he's working on playing right away. We'll see....

HarlemCoug

1/3/17 3:55pm

Had forgotten about England. I know some smart folks who really liked him.

BGRTHNUMEGO

1/3/17 3:36pm

Empey is a done deal

scottm

1/3/17 6:48pm

Will Sedgwick will return in early February, not March

Hawk Talons

1/3/17 8:51pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad