The greatest player ever is debatable for sure

Jul 24, 2017
8:14:41am

gww687 Playmaker

I think the thing that isn't debatable is that Jimmer had the greatest single season ever (individually that is). I don't think you can argue that one. Greatest player is a different discussion.

Report problem with this ad

gww687

Bio page: gww687
Joined: May 16, 2010
Last login: Jun 6, 2024
Total posts: 4,485 (17 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Blog: BYU basketball: Jimmer Fredette agrees to deal with Sharks to remain in Shanghai View

[Lawless Republic] Nathan Cunningham

7/23/17 9:45pm

BYU's greatest player ever eh?

Seasider

7/23/17 10:05pm

Kinda hard to argue that one

Dissenter

7/23/17 10:07pm

Some argue Danny Ainge was the greatest.

Lieutenant America

7/23/17 10:15pm

Yes, I love Jimmer, but Ainge was on another level. Not as a pure scorer, but

spoxjox

7/23/17 10:23pm

I don't think even Danny would make today's nba

gmj81

7/23/17 10:28pm

I think he would. Ainge was bigger, faster, stronger, more aggressive, and

spoxjox

7/23/17 10:30pm

There is an age gap here on CB. Very few on here can actually lay claim to

Cougarfan777

7/23/17 10:34pm

Baseball? That's what we're using for athletic standards now? Interesting.

Disco LaFleur

7/23/17 10:38pm

You don't consider that applicable? Yet he's one of only two players since

Cougarfan777

7/23/17 10:47pm

He was also one of the few people to ever be All American in three sports.

MAcc15Coug

7/23/17 10:51pm

Well, I think Jim Thorpe was an even better athlete. Are you even old enough to

Disco LaFleur

7/23/17 11:04pm

No, I'm not, so I wouldn't even comment. I'd leave it to those that watched him

Cougarfan777

7/23/17 11:10pm

Let's just agree that Jim Thorpe was the greatest athlete and call it a night.

Disco LaFleur

7/23/17 11:25pm

Deal. Although he wouldn't make today's NBA.

Cougarfan777

7/23/17 11:36pm

He hates today's NBA.

Disco LaFleur

7/23/17 11:38pm

Please. Ainge was a major contributor on some of the best Celtic teams ever.

Cougarfan777

7/23/17 10:31pm

And most of those guys wouldn't play in today's NBA either

gmj81

7/23/17 10:35pm

Please stop. Don't make me name them. Okay I will. McHale? DJ? Parish? Um...

Cougarfan777

7/23/17 10:40pm

Mchale weighed 210 pounds, at PF he would get thrown around, that's 15 pounds

califcougar

7/24/17 1:17am

Charles Barkley has said many times that McHale was the greatest player he

Cougarfan777

7/24/17 1:32am

Nice video. Vs Jabbar, Willis, Sampson, Ewing, Rollins, Laimbeer, Wilkins, etc

j20

7/24/17 7:58am

His playing weight later was 225. With his 8' wingspan, he'd be fine.

j20

7/24/17 8:08am

1986 players were 3.5 lbs lighter, but 0.6" taller on average vs 2015.

j20

7/24/17 8:13am

Wrong. Guy started on 3 NBA teams (Celtics, Trailblazers, Phoenix) that went to

HootnHoller

7/24/17 8:35am

wrong.. Ainge was all around much better.

byukarl

7/24/17 11:54am

Best BYU athlete hands down; one of best athletes, period says this guy:

Monomachos

7/23/17 11:31pm

The accomplishments mentioned in that video were even more than I realized.

Cougarfan777

7/23/17 11:43pm

Thanks for sharing. I knew most of this stuff, but had never seen this video.

lbmango

7/24/17 10:51am

Are you serious?

Seasider

7/23/17 10:17pm

Are you serious?

Disco LaFleur

7/23/17 10:42pm

Yes I am serious and don't call me Shirley.

Seasider

7/23/17 10:51pm

I realize an argument can be made either way. Jimmer's my favorite. Was he the

Disco LaFleur

7/23/17 11:06pm

Yes

Disco LaFleur

7/23/17 10:23pm

The greatest player ever is debatable for sure

gww687

7/24/17 8:14am

the BYU. Now I guess we are tBYU.

Ssebo

7/23/17 10:19pm

What do you mean? It's always been "the BYU", at least to grandpa's generation.

spoxjox

7/23/17 10:23pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad