There might be a diamond in the rough but right now it looks pretty rough.

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

May 1, 2024
11:04:07am

BYU Fan All-American

There might be a diamond in the rough but right now it looks pretty rough.

Report problem with this ad

BYU Fan

Bio page: BYU Fan
Joined: Mar 7, 2002
Last login: Jun 15, 2024
Total posts: 24,546 (1,085 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

When is the last time BYU had a QB situation this bad going into the year?

TCuz Coastal Elite

May 1, 10:54am

Crowton after Doman graduated.

May 1, 10:55am

RE: Crowton after Doman graduated.

kansascougar

May 1, 10:55am

Ben Olson was a top recruit coming in that year

BYU Fan

May 1, 11:01am

Jake Heaps and Riley Nelson, Tanner Mangum, I think there is actually a lot over

Cougs or die

May 1, 10:55am

I don’t think so with Tanner Mangum. In 2015-2016 the starter heading into the year was Taysom

TCuz

May 1, 10:58am

All three would be preferable to JR

byuTX

May 1, 12:19pm

We do not know if it’s bad. One of the options could be really good.

kC Cougar

May 1, 10:56am

I think we know, unfortunately.

TCuz

May 1, 10:58am

There might be a diamond in the rough but right now it looks pretty rough.

BYU Fan

May 1, 11:04am

2017 was pretty bad. 2010-13. 2002-03

May 1, 10:57am

Even when Wilson and Hall were recruited they didn't come in with much hype, if

SUAVO

May 1, 10:59am

BYU found two needles in the haystack with Jaren and Zach. That lucky streak has ended

letthewookieewin

May 1, 11:03am

ZW didn't really become himself until his Jr yr and The same for hall. Even

SUAVO

May 1, 11:08am

It was lucky they were both as good as they were but both had significant P5 interest

puntersarepeople

May 1, 11:11am

We had Tanner Mangum coming off an amazing 2015 freshman season in 2017

BYU Fan

May 1, 11:02am

We had Tanner coming off a 2015 season where

May 1, 1:51pm

A lot, and I mean A TON, will depend on how the OL does. The ship will sink or

SUAVO

May 1, 11:01am

The year after Bosco left. Yikes.

BlueFever

May 1, 11:02am

The year? errr ... years

ManicBlue

May 1, 11:31am

True.

BlueFever

May 1, 11:32am

Not this bad since 1903 when we started Phineas Young II

The Y's Insider

May 1, 11:04am

Why are you convinced the sky is falling on the QB room?

AzCugrFan

May 1, 11:40am

Seriously?

TCuz

May 1, 11:44am

Yes, seriously. Also, what exactly qualifies you to be an expert on a QB room?

AzCugrFan

May 1, 11:52am

I have 20+ years of NFL and college scouting experience, including significant film study and statistical analysis.

TCuz

May 1, 12:17pm

And what exactly are you doing with this wealth of knowledge you've garnered?

AzCugrFan

May 1, 1:51pm

It doesn't take an expert to know that our QB room based on previous performance

CameronG

May 1, 12:27pm

Um .. not quite

ManicBlue

May 1, 1:14pm

Keep telling yourself that

CameronG

May 1, 1:58pm

Remind me too ... after Bohanon led Baylor to a B12 title and a 12-2 record, how did Baylor do with his replacement and

ManicBlue

May 1, 2:00pm

You only have to go to last year.

bluegaucho

May 1, 1:39pm

No way. Slovis didn’t play great, but that was a much better situation heading into the year the current group.

TCuz

May 1, 1:43pm

Any hope of great qb play was lost after game 1.

bluegaucho

May 1, 2:25pm

Went from fine/serviceable to disastrous once slovis went down

byuTX

May 1, 3:04pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad