Of course he only had one carry in his BYU career...I guess that may be a bit too small of a sample size. Realistically, Staley is a given IMO, nobody in the top 10 rushers comes close to his ypc average over his career, especially not when he was in top form his last season. (he averaged like 8 yards a carry didn't he?) On top of that he was a TD machine. I'd probably have to say Jenkins, but Brathwaite was also an explosive back and would be in the running, too bad he wasn't around too long.