Facts are Facts

Oct 9, 2015
9:20:56am

CasualFan

Facts are Facts

BYU didn't win those games because Max was awesome.

They won in spite of his poor performances.

Max was a great competitor. HE didn't beat Utah.

Report problem with this ad

CasualFan

Bio page: CasualFan
Joined: Sep 29, 2014
Last login: May 5, 2024
Total posts: 3,234 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Top 5 Max Hall wins?

bushy7

10/9/15 9:06am

TCU 2007 was also a good one.

Dangerous

10/9/15 9:08am

Before TCU left us in the dust with their speed advantage.

mantis mutu

10/9/15 9:23am

Does Max Hall win mean he had a good game, or just a win?

SandYFan

10/9/15 9:09am

Win against a good opponent.

bushy7

10/9/15 9:10am

So if, for example, if Max went 12-32 for 132 yards in a win against Utah, that

SandYFan

10/9/15 9:14am

Was Hall the starting QB? Did we win? Yes, that's how it works in the record

Left Shark Coug

10/9/15 9:15am

Okey doke.

SandYFan

10/9/15 9:20am

Yep

bushy7

10/9/15 9:17am

Wounded, underthrown duck to Collie on a blown coverage.

SandYFan

10/9/15 9:26am

Wasn't he on the run with the throw to Collie?

RaggaeCoug

10/9/15 10:03am

Wasn't Hall injured also? Sprained shoulder or something? It was great he got

ol' Blue Eyes

10/9/15 10:37am

Since Detmer, only Hancock, Doman, and Hall have a winning record vs Utah.

Left Shark Coug

10/9/15 9:13am

And Max can thank his lucky stars the defense showed up to those two wins

SandYFan

10/9/15 9:14am

Do you have a issue with Max?

bushy7

10/9/15 9:18am

Facts are Facts

CasualFan

10/9/15 9:20am

No, I just think people give him waaaaay too much credit when he sucked against

SandYFan

10/9/15 9:20am

Do you whine when Sark gets credited for beating Utah, Wyoming or KState in '96?

Left Shark Coug

10/9/15 9:28am

This is a weird argument. Sark was fine in those games.

SandYFan

10/9/15 9:32am

Throw in Rice, as well. Can't credit a QB with a win if he didn't do anything.

Left Shark Coug

10/9/15 9:40am

As long as you agree that 12-32 for 132 is a poor performance, okay.

SandYFan

10/9/15 9:42am

Never said it was

bushy7

10/9/15 9:50am

Hall's family once poured beer on Sandy's family.

Left Shark Coug

10/9/15 9:21am

It wasn't even good beer.

SandYFan

10/9/15 9:27am

Max Hall was 2-1 against Utah

WJCougar

10/9/15 9:29am

I think that would count as a winning record

bushy7

10/9/15 9:30am

It sure does. If you want to ignore context and detail, that's fine.

SandYFan

10/9/15 9:33am

Ignoring context is exactly what you do when you rely solely on stats.

spugeddy24

10/9/15 9:39am

Well.... Good to know that you care more about how a QB plays instead of him

bushy7

10/9/15 9:48am

Not true.

SandYFan

10/9/15 10:08am

But the best win ever was Beck to Harline on their turf. That counts x10

DazeofBlue

10/9/15 11:33am

Oregon State 2009 was probably our peak as a team in his years.

mantis mutu

10/9/15 9:25am

Also the last season our on the field performance was something to be proud of

byutx

10/9/15 9:42am

A predestined savior, his gritty nemesis & our home-grown genius made sure of it

mantis mutu

10/9/15 10:06am

He cursed us after his last Utah game. We need the curse lifted.

spugeddy24

10/9/15 9:26am

I'm pretty sure that it's Bronco's curse

TheDeek

10/9/15 9:33am

Bronco was 3-2 against Utah until the Hall "I hate Utah" speech.

spugeddy24

10/9/15 9:35am

Stats from all 5 games...

saltlakecoug1

10/9/15 10:08am

<< Deleted >>

saltlakecoug1

10/9/15 10:08am

He appears to have beaten addiction. That is the most important win of all.

lilpenny

10/9/15 1:41pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad