To be fair, asking to Utah fans, we're there officiating calls that helped

Report problem with this ad

Aug 20, 2017
9:41:52am

BYUHgrad All-American

BYU...especially egregious?

Report problem with this ad

BYUHgrad

Previous username: Big Island Thunder
Bio page: BYUHgrad
Joined: Feb 6, 2008
Last login: May 2, 2024
Total posts: 12,728 (2,221 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Rewatched the 2016 BYU/Utah game

Bryceo19

8/19/17 9:45pm

Pretty good take.

jkccoug

8/19/17 9:57pm

5.A. was the play that infuriated me the most.

Chemish

8/19/17 9:59pm

Officials ruin football. Time to innovate.

BYUALWAYSNUM1

8/19/17 10:02pm

No, corruption ruins football. Out of conference games should be officiated

Bryceo19

8/19/17 10:24pm

You mean like the officials in last year's game?

Scratch

8/19/17 10:48pm

To be fair, asking to Utah fans, we're there officiating calls that helped

BYUHgrad

8/20/17 9:41am

Fair question.

Bryceo19

8/20/17 10:58am

Probably. I certainly remember being frustrated with various calls or non-calls

Scratch

8/20/17 11:18am

This is why I asked. If BYU converts the 2 point concersion

BYUHgrad

8/20/17 2:14pm

Do you mean like the Big XII officials that officiated BYU/Utah 2016?

61_Shasta

8/19/17 10:56pm

Link?

Bryceo19

8/19/17 11:08pm

Ok, let me do your research for you.

61_Shasta

8/19/17 11:20pm

Did you just link to a comment you made on a CB thread? Well played!

Bryceo19

8/19/17 11:30pm

Because it's been discussed ad nauseum

61_Shasta

8/19/17 11:45pm

ad nauseum = one thread a couple months ago

Bryceo19

8/20/17 5:25am

Here you go, from BYU's athletics website.

Scratch

8/20/17 8:16am

AND looks like it was at minimum PAC-12 officials in replay booth

Bryceo19

8/19/17 11:38pm

Google that too. It's standard

61_Shasta

8/19/17 11:50pm

Yes, Google is a good source. Thank you.

Bryceo19

8/20/17 5:20am

I say take the human element out of the game. It's 2017. Use technology.

BYUALWAYSNUM1

8/20/17 7:59am

I can see how you'd automate something like calling balls and strikes, but football reffing seems way more subjective

Roko's Basilisk

8/20/17 9:26am

Oh it would be super expensive. But we have the ability to have cameras and

BYUALWAYSNUM1

8/20/17 9:56am

Yeah, ball spotting and chain placement seem like particulalry bad things to leave up to humans.

Roko's Basilisk

8/20/17 10:19am

Great take. The Nacua targeting made me the most mad in the moment, but 5A anger

RUNBYU1

8/19/17 10:03pm

Question on A. Why and how would 5 yards get missed by

Tuskaloosa Cougar

8/19/17 10:03pm

I think most people would go with a forward progress excuse, but that is a

SUAVO

8/19/17 10:08pm

looked like F. Warner tried to get an explanation

Bryceo19

8/19/17 10:22pm

wait so what is the rule with forward progress?

ColonelMustard

8/20/17 2:09pm

Are you serious Clark?

Bryceo19

8/20/17 2:35pm

I've long believed the PAC officials protect their teams

Borg

8/19/17 10:21pm

And so do most outside of the PAC 10.2

tander123

8/19/17 10:28pm

RE: I've long believed the PAC officials protect their teams

JustmeintheSLC

8/19/17 10:33pm

And for the 9000th time, REPLAY officials, bro. They were PAC 11.1

SPgoofyft

8/20/17 8:47am

For me the Jamaal face mask was the most egregious. As obvious as a facemask

Cougar76

8/19/17 10:27pm

Thanks for the clarification on JW face mask.

Bryceo19

8/19/17 10:37pm

except it was a big 12 ref right? While it was a missed call I don't get your

ColonelMustard

8/20/17 2:11pm

You can keep pushing the "they were Big 12 refs"

Bryceo19

8/20/17 2:35pm

We lost our two best players on absolutely awful calls. Nacua

Cougar76

8/19/17 10:36pm

In hindsight I'm shocked they didn't rule Taysom out on his 1st TD run.

Bryceo19

8/19/17 10:39pm

Looking at the replays shown,

KCRoyalcoug

8/19/17 10:59pm

Oh yeah, I remember that crappy spotting job. Gave them a whole free 5 yards.

Harrison0Yfan

8/19/17 10:56pm

Who was the PI on in 5a?

Gerald-DeGroot

8/20/17 3:02am

It was Wilcox.

Gerald-DeGroot

8/20/17 9:54pm

No way!

Gerald-DeGroot

8/20/17 9:54pm

Chaz Ah You is now at LB behind F. Warner, FYI.

Six Foot Seven

8/20/17 5:47am

Really? I think he's better staying at Safety personally.

Bryceo19

8/20/17 6:55am

He's getting a bit too big for safety

Martin Van Nostrand

8/20/17 9:23am

Dare I ask...which conf is officiating this year's game?

zerome4sooners

8/20/17 6:16am

Presumably P12 because it's in Provo.

Scratch

8/20/17 8:17am

Although BYU will provide replay officials, so watch out for Chad Bunn.

Scratch

8/20/17 8:51am

Stupid big 12 refs trying to help a PAC 12 school!

ironman1315

8/20/17 9:44am

Solid analysis but I have to disagree with #2 and your final thoughts.

BigBrotherUte

8/20/17 11:48am

My husband and I remember that terrible spot! It was ridiculous!!

Posting on CougarBoard