The pumpkin pie is not good, but their pumpkin cheesecake is delicious.

Oct 23, 2016
5:17:57pm

specsauce All-American

And I've always thought their regular cheesecake is inedible as well. I was really shocked at how good the pumpkin cheesecake is.

Report problem with this ad

specsauce

Previous username: dukehauser
Bio page: specsauce
Joined: Sep 19, 2002
Last login: Jun 5, 2024
Total posts: 11,823 (173 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

This might be controversial, and people might hate me for saying it, but

BYUtka

10/23/16 5:03pm

The Costco qualifier of "pumpkin pie" was unnecessary.

jordbyu

10/23/16 5:06pm

Pumpkin pie is OK with enough Whipped cream, as long as you take most of the

cougaman

10/23/16 6:59pm

I love it with good whip cream but I'm not a pie connoisseur by any means.

Cabadapeste

10/23/16 5:08pm

It's palatable with a whip cream to pie ratio of 3:1

kotacoug

10/23/16 6:08pm

The pumpkin pie is not good, but their pumpkin cheesecake is delicious.

specsauce

10/23/16 5:17pm

As are their pumpkin muffins.

BYUtka

10/23/16 5:19pm

"You're a pumpkin muffin" would make an excellent personal attack

TNT

10/23/16 6:04pm

A delicious personal attack!

BYUtka

10/23/16 6:05pm

Any pumpkin pie is not that great. So many better choices of pie.

idacoug

10/23/16 5:31pm

This is the big secret. And people like my wife will kill you for saying it.

RalphWiggam

10/23/16 5:34pm

Amen.

idacoug

10/23/16 5:55pm

Pumpkin Pie is the only pie worth eating... The rest are all wannabees

TheDeek

10/23/16 5:36pm

Chocolate pudding pies are fantastic

TNT

10/23/16 6:04pm

Delete your account

shakinbaker

10/23/16 6:07pm

pecan is the king of pies

gilbertatty

10/23/16 6:09pm

Too much sugar. TNT gains weight just looking at them

TNT

10/23/16 6:14pm

<< Deleted >>

Abe Froman

10/23/16 6:11pm

Only in regards to pie. Besides, I'm more of a cake eater anyway

TheDeek

10/23/16 8:17pm

Having grown up with a mother that made really good pies, and was known for

RebelScum

10/23/16 5:38pm

Give an example of a good nationwide or regional available pumpkin pie.

84 Grad

10/23/16 6:00pm

Marie Calendar's is decent.

BYUtka

10/23/16 6:03pm

There's one in town...I'm give it a try

84 Grad

10/23/16 6:08pm

Most grocery stores sell them in the freezer section. Might be easier.

BYUtka

10/23/16 6:18pm

Many pumpkin pie lovers won't like this, but I can't stomach any pumpkin pie.

Dixie's Red Rocks

10/23/16 6:51pm

I think you're only supposed to eat pumpkin pie once a year

RunningQB

10/23/16 6:53pm

We buy an extra pumpkin at Halloween and make pumpkin pie with it at Thanksgiving.

Posting on CougarBoard