My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Apr 26, 2017
2:18
:19
pm
Florwood
All-American
Koufax for pitcher.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Florwood
Bio page
Florwood
Joined
Mar 10, 2010
Last login
Oct 31, 2024
Total posts
27,875 (76 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
What would your all time lineup be if you could pick any players ever?
sgriff
4/26/17 11:19am
Bonds and Ruth are always at the top of any WAR or VORP list.
d-coug
4/26/17 11:24am
Bonds was a jerk and his numbers inflated by roids and Ruth an alcoholic.
sgriff
4/26/17 11:27am
Yet you have Cobb on there...
foofcoug
4/26/17 11:29am
There is a lot of mis information about Cobb out there. Read this article:
sgriff
4/26/17 11:37am
Ty Cobb
Gigo
4/26/17 1:11pm
And the stories of Ted Williams alcoholism are well known too.
The Old Y
4/26/17 11:44am
Didn't know about Ted's alcoholism. I could be talked into a switch for Ruth.
sgriff
4/26/17 12:05pm
If you have 12 minutes, Bonds is the greatest baseball player of all time:
specialk08
4/26/17 1:06pm
I know. I just don't like him and wouldn't want to lose him to drug testing.
sgriff
4/26/17 1:12pm
Yes. He was found guilty of obstruction of justice but never found guilty of
specialk08
4/26/17 1:19pm
RE: What would your all time lineup be if you could pick any players ever?
donnerstag
4/26/17 11:24am
Lineup by JAWS Leaders
Ackman
4/26/17 11:52am
Lol. My brain read Warren Sapp, not Warren Spahn.
LeftOfNormal
4/26/17 12:00pm
RE: What would your all time lineup be if you could pick any players ever?
smokymountainrain
4/26/17 11:28am
You're going to risk steroid guys? They're going to get caught with modern tests
sgriff
4/26/17 11:43am
I think you need to add Mantle, Dimaggio, and Rose
Samuel Hall Society
4/26/17 11:35am
who does he take off? i think he's sticking with 9 guys in the lineup.
smokymountainrain
4/26/17 11:39am
Over Who?
sgriff
4/26/17 11:42am
Nolan Ryan as the SP. Love ya Gibson, but come on now.
The Old Y
4/26/17 11:42am
Found this description of Gibson online:
sgriff
4/26/17 12:15pm
Wagner was a SS, wasn't he?
JDBlue
4/26/17 11:43am
Yes. He was.
donnerstag
4/26/17 12:57pm
Yes, but I think any great SS could transition to 2B easily enough.
sgriff
4/26/17 12:58pm
If you don't have bonds, you don't have the best lineup ever.
Josef K
4/26/17 11:46am
Or Tony Gwynn. The best "hitter" in the modern era. Highly underated.
The Old Y
4/26/17 11:50am
I did consider Gwynn pretty hard. tough to leave him off. might be worth
sgriff
4/26/17 12:10pm
I can't have any team without Griffey. I firmly believe he was the best outfielder of all time.
indocoug
4/26/17 11:52am
Wow. Pudge over Bench? Shoot, I'd put a couple CURRENT catchers over Pudge.
LeftOfNormal
4/26/17 11:55am
yeah. Not too sure about that pick either. I could easily be swayed.
sgriff
4/26/17 12:02pm
Yeah, you'll notice I didn't mention WHICH current C's, for a similar reason.
LeftOfNormal
4/26/17 12:09pm
Pudge is the best defensive catcher there was. Also a solid .296 batting average and one of the faster catchers
indocoug
4/26/17 12:17pm
I was thinking Yadier Molina for Defense and game management but he is slow
sgriff
4/26/17 12:20pm
Except that Ivan was a way better hitter than Molina (and just as good as Posey), but a much better defender
indocoug
4/26/17 12:43pm
That's why I picked him for my lineup.
sgriff
4/26/17 12:57pm
I'd probably choose Yadi or Buster. When all is said and done, both players will
LeftOfNormal
4/26/17 12:32pm
My List:
The Old Y
4/26/17 12:05pm
you're list has 7 outfielders. Who's playing playing the infield?
sgriff
4/26/17 12:08pm
It does not matter. I'm playing short though. Already Called it.
The Old Y
4/26/17 12:09pm
I'll take Ozzie over the old Y any day
sgriff
4/26/17 12:11pm
Me too!
The Old Y
4/26/17 12:14pm
Ok. Since this is your game, and you force me to do it:
The Old Y
4/26/17 12:13pm
You know, you COULD pitch Ruth if you really couldn't find an OF spot. I bet
LeftOfNormal
4/26/17 12:17pm
Ruth as a pitcher and hitter combo is interesting for a single game apporach.
sgriff
4/26/17 12:25pm
I always knew he pitched early in his career but never assumed he was any better
LeftOfNormal
4/26/17 12:38pm
It's amazing how truly great he was at both pitching and hitting.
sgriff
4/26/17 12:56pm
Willimas would be a liabilty in center and Ruth couldn't squat down for more
sgriff
4/26/17 12:23pm
Will be interesting to see where Mike Trout ends up in 10 years
BYUheaven
4/26/17 12:05pm
Koufax for pitcher.
Florwood
4/26/17 2:18pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad