I can't think of a game situation where I have to catch the punt

Jul 26, 2017
11:29:17am

BYU Fan All-American

I realize that in this imaginary scenario we are requiring it but as long as I don't let the punt hit me, my team still wins.

Report problem with this ad

BYU Fan

Bio page: BYU Fan
Joined: Mar 7, 2002
Last login: Jun 1, 2024
Total posts: 24,496 (1,081 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The game is on the line and it's all up to you. You have several options....

rtNelson

7/26/17 10:24am

Deep Route: 75% chance, maybe 85-90% if perfect throw

HeismanTy

7/26/17 10:27am

Am I a coach, a player?

Zedhead

7/26/17 10:28am

You are the player, doing the actual kicking/catching. In your current physic.

rtNelson

7/26/17 10:29am

Deep route with or without a perfect throw

BYuckner

7/26/17 10:29am

Yeah, I think the undefended bit made it a no-brainer. Derp.

rtNelson

7/26/17 10:33am

Am I already 40-50 yards downfield?

ColoSpgs

7/26/17 10:51am

Bernard is playing corner.

cougfanblue

7/26/17 11:04am

Ask Ross Apo how that worked out for him.

Bluedomination

7/26/17 10:57am

Catching a pass that deep, coming that fast is actually not that easy

Machiavelli

7/26/17 12:16pm

Pass

PhilPete

7/26/17 10:31am

Holy crap I'll take the deep ball

Dissenter

7/26/17 10:33am

Wait... I'd take the punt, and I wouldn't catch it. The defense touches it dead

Dissenter

7/26/17 10:39am

Obviously you would at least have to attempt to catch it.

rtNelson

7/26/17 10:41am

then the deep ball. It's easier, and catching the game winning TD would be sweet

Dissenter

7/26/17 10:46am

Agreed, I regret putting that option in there. But I do laugh at the thought...

rtNelson

7/26/17 10:50am

Fielding a punt is easier than catching a 50 yard pass

Left Shark Coug

7/26/17 11:07am

the velocity on the punt is going to be higher, unless the punter sucks

Dissenter

7/26/17 11:57am

The y component of the velocity, sure, but not the x component.

Left Shark Coug

7/26/17 6:42pm

If you actually have to field the punt, IMO by far the hardest.

HeismanTy

7/26/17 10:36am

I think the odds of me catching a punt are > an extra point with no practice.

rtNelson

7/26/17 10:40am

I can see, that, the difference with the punt for me is the game scenario

HeismanTy

7/26/17 10:44am

Have you seen the times when they bring fans on the field during timeouts to

jensen46

7/26/17 11:10am

Option #3

yaxcoug

7/26/17 10:41am

Wouldn't the best option be to pick the punt and get out of the way?

BYU Fan

7/26/17 11:02am

You are the person that's supposed to catch the punt I believe. No practicing.

(Private)

7/26/17 11:10am

I can't think of a game situation where I have to catch the punt

BYU Fan

7/26/17 11:29am

Kick the field goal

DrKennethNoisewater

7/26/17 11:03am

I would suck at all of them. I would just run away from the punt and hope the

jensen46

7/26/17 11:08am

I'm a kicker... I'd take the chipshot for the win.

(Private)

7/26/17 11:09am

Fans would be confused why a lineman was kicking the field goal though...

(Private)

7/26/17 11:11am

Can we see a preview?

yaxcoug

7/26/17 11:14am

Don't want to be suspended again...

(Private)

7/26/17 11:15am

But would be something along these lines though

(Private)

7/26/17 11:18am

That was awesome. Thank you.

yaxcoug

7/26/17 11:20am

Can I wave for a fair catch before the ball is snapped?

El Pasco

7/26/17 11:12am

65 toss power trap...and it will bust wide open...even win the super bowl

84 Grad

7/26/17 11:15am

Kick it

D.T. Survivor

7/26/17 11:15am

I field the punt. Standing and catching a punt is easier than a deep bomb I'm

SLIVER

7/26/17 11:24am

Field the punt

KCRoyalcoug

7/26/17 11:26am

The punt. The pass is a live play meaning my QB is dead long b4 I get to 50

thecthdox

7/26/17 11:29am

The punt.

lightmann

7/26/17 11:49am

Fair catch with the punt

Harrison0Yfan

7/26/17 1:28pm

Catch punt 80%, catch pass 80%, field goal 40%

BringYourUltimate

7/26/17 1:45pm

I totally could do both 1 and 2 but would need to bring a lawn chair and some...

icecougar

7/26/17 1:53pm

Deep route easy.

Ham

7/26/17 2:07pm

I'd kick it. Easy chip shot. Laces out and I'm money.

Posting on CougarBoard