How is it not even close?

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 23, 2017
11:13:02am

eddog All-American

How is it not even close?

I think you're vastly underestimating the popularity of Young and McMahon.

Report problem with this ad

eddog

Bio page: eddog
Joined: Dec 1, 2009
Last login: Oct 6, 2020
Total posts: 18,223 (415 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Who's the most beloved former Cougar?

eddog

9/23/17 10:51am

The one from that one tv show...oh wait

MWKV3

9/23/17 10:53am

It's still Ty.

HeismanTy

9/23/17 10:55am

K Heisman Ty lol

9/23/17 3:41pm

I was on the front row for Miami

Jacob

9/23/17 10:55am

Ty still is top 3

9/23/17 10:55am

if not limited to football

Jacob

9/23/17 11:00am

Agreed. No matter what he does from here on out, he should always be top 3.

9/23/17 11:04am

It's Ty Detmer and not really close

2FarGone

9/23/17 11:04am

How is it not even close?

eddog

9/23/17 11:13am

Young and McMahon did not have the demeanor of Detmer

2FarGone

9/23/17 11:20am

Interesting perspective. Agree to disagree.

eddog

9/23/17 11:24am

Jim McMahon. He destroyed Utah and was the best pure passer BYU has.

Cougs 96-97

9/23/17 11:32am

Yeah, Steve Young isn't even close.... right

pistol12

9/23/17 2:34pm

I want him gone as soon as the season's over. That doesn't

mantis mutu

9/23/17 11:13am

Vai, Buck, Hans, Whit

I'mBatman

9/23/17 11:13am

Now that's certainly a different angle.

mantis mutu

9/23/17 11:15am

for 40 years it was kresimir cosic, the football gods took over

Nat Gas Man

9/23/17 11:22am

Jimmy. When they recognized all the great QB's a few years ago

Mathew

9/23/17 11:23am

The Heisman trophy winner.

cougfanblue

9/23/17 11:31am

Interesting question....generational biases might make a consensus difficult

Michael McQuain

9/23/17 11:39am

Ainge is my fav... he's represented the church well in his endevours.

9/23/17 12:19pm

Jimmer?

ugo1st

9/23/17 12:57pm

Decent argument. Jimmermania was no joke. His senior year has been one of my

Stucoug83

9/23/17 1:23pm

Kyle Whittingham

CrimsonCardinal

9/23/17 12:57pm

Nice try LoL.

Rocketman

9/23/17 1:21pm

Lavell

Jacob

9/23/17 1:17pm

Ty, JW, and I still love Sark. His '96 was such a great year.

Santos L. Halper

9/23/17 1:29pm

Bryan Kehl

A Man in Full

9/23/17 2:27pm

Jim McMahon wins out for me. Even though Steve was great Jim had the moxy and

9/23/17 3:14pm

Ty Detmer

MaxxPower

9/23/17 6:11pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad