Remind us, who are you? What credentials do you have to make that judgment?

Report problem with this ad

Oct 23, 2017
8:52:35pm

Division Bell Contributor

Report problem with this ad

Division Bell

Previous username: BluePete
Bio page: Division Bell
Joined: Jul 20, 2002
Last login: Jun 1, 2024
Total posts: 96,754 (18,650 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Interesting fact about Ty. He's thrown the most INTs of any QB in BYU history

Bryceo19

10/23/17 7:43pm

*fewer TDs

Duke Silver

10/23/17 7:46pm

I've said this all along. Let Mangum throw 3 picks a game and 3 TD's, it won't

Cougarfan777

10/23/17 7:47pm

Is a long pass INT really any worse than a 3 and out?

mudpupper

10/23/17 7:50pm

It's much better, because if it's not an INT it's an immediate TD. There is

Cougarfan777

10/23/17 7:55pm

Not many guys played 4 straight years. But, yes that’s a lot of INTs

The Dude Abides

10/23/17 7:47pm

Four straight years and he threw a lot of balls.

Tuskaloosa Cougar

10/23/17 8:57pm

2-1 TD/INT ratio is fine with me. If a QB throws 30 TDs and 15 INTs that’s ok with me.

SlantRoute

10/23/17 7:48pm

Especially in the late '80s and early '90s. The game has changed a lot since

Game Changer

10/23/17 7:53pm

he also lost the next FIVE games, badly, after winning the Heisman; he is a nice

insidebyu

10/23/17 7:50pm

He had a solid NFL career to boot. He is not overrated.

titlecoug

10/23/17 7:53pm

Let's take all our heroes and cut their playing career down to size

cougarmanguy

10/23/17 7:57pm

Lucky overachiever? Worst Heisman Trophy winner ever? You really don't know much

Game Changer

10/23/17 7:58pm

Probably wasn't alive in 1994. #millenials

Bryceo19

10/23/17 8:24pm

Context to consider if you're fair minded enough (which i seriously doubt)

CLCougar

10/23/17 8:02pm

Semanoff didn’t play with Ty, and he had great byu WRs his entire career.

macaroni

10/23/17 8:13pm

You are correct on Semanoff, my bad....i just knew it wasn't a strong group

CLCougar

10/23/17 8:28pm

Joe Semanoff was a fullback and he played over a Decade after Ty.

akmewg

10/23/17 8:20pm

And I think he's on CB, could probably bear testimony of this

Game Changer

10/23/17 8:23pm

Wow. Just. Wow. This is a guy who won the heismsn in his worst year. That's

smokymountainrain

10/23/17 8:02pm

Stop being rational...some of these people are in a frenzy and lashing out.

CLCougar

10/23/17 8:04pm

If you really think that, you don’t watch much football and you never watched him play. Heck, look at his contemporary

macaroni

10/23/17 8:12pm

Nobody is asking you to be a fan. There are other programs that you can cheer

crazY

10/23/17 8:12pm

Remind us, who are you? What credentials do you have to make that judgment?

Division Bell

10/23/17 8:52pm

HOT TAKE ALERT!!!!

UberDeek

10/23/17 10:03pm

I have been very harsh of ty the coach but ty the player deserved everything he

nashty

10/23/17 11:01pm

Yeah he just broke like 50 NCAA records by happenstance...(eye roll)

ColonelMustard

10/24/17 4:06pm

Boardname fail. Delete your account.

Abe Froman

10/24/17 10:29pm

Not really comparing Mangum to Detmer or INTs and TDs.

Bryceo19

10/23/17 7:56pm

I dunno...

teancum

10/24/17 10:06am

Can't really compare Doman to Ty since Doman only played started his senior yea

akmewg

10/23/17 7:58pm

What does his playing career have to do with anything?

macaroni

10/23/17 7:59pm

Let me spell it out for you.

Bryceo19

10/23/17 8:07pm

Let me spell it out for you: Totally irrelevant to his current position.

macaroni

10/23/17 8:14pm

Everything is relavent. This is CB!

Bryceo19

10/23/17 8:19pm

No, it's not.

crazY

10/23/17 8:21pm

Yes, it is!

Bryceo19

10/23/17 8:25pm

No. Just, no.

crazY

10/23/17 8:27pm

Yes. Just, yes!

Bryceo19

10/23/17 8:34pm

I think you're trolling. Not everything is relevant on CB. Only relevant info

crazY

10/23/17 8:42pm

Yes, only relevant info is relavent. Like Ty's playing and coaching careers.

Bryceo19

10/23/17 8:46pm

But his coaching is irrelevant to his playing.

crazY

10/23/17 8:49pm

Clearly in your opinion. Thank you. I respectfully disagree.

Bryceo19

10/23/17 9:00pm

How are the two relevant?

crazY

10/23/17 9:17pm

I’m pretty sure this is CB actually.

(Private)

10/23/17 9:32pm

Killer instinct? I could forgive him if he was too aggressive and that lead to

akmewg

10/23/17 8:17pm

So, you're saying we should expect the most losing seasons in BYU history, and

Thunder Buddy

10/23/17 7:59pm

No. I'm not talking about wins and losses. That's a team thing.

Bryceo19

10/23/17 8:09pm

What part of Detmer's playcalling suggests to you that he is willing to take

OlanchoCoug

10/24/17 10:25am

We should have benched Ty.

dYrtbYkerYder

10/23/17 8:05pm

For Sean Covey? Right! Bench the guy with 2:1 TD:INT for guy with 1:1.

Bryceo19

10/23/17 8:17pm

No and no.

Go_Trojans

10/23/17 8:58pm

Not only did he play four straight years

Cougarpride

10/23/17 9:43pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad