You're comparing apples to oranges. Beck's throw has never been done before or

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Apr 3, 2024
9:32:13pm

Threw and Through Redshirt Freshman

You're comparing apples to oranges. Beck's throw has never been done before or

after by a BYU QB. Brown's catch has at least two equals in BYU history (Koslowski and Mathews, with strong competition from Hoffman and Pau'u as well). In my opinion, Beck's throw was more difficult than Brown's catch, but both were spectacular and historic.

Report problem with this ad

Threw and Through

Bio page: Threw and Through
Joined: Aug 2, 2002
Last login: Jun 5, 2024
Total posts: 199 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: You get final say on the greatest single play in BYU FB history

Future_Tacos

Apr 2, 9:06pm

Kyle Morrell

foofcoug

Apr 2, 9:07pm

Single-handedly saving the national championship season.

Blue Print

Apr 2, 9:21pm

Awesome play, but this is an exaggeration.

Y05

Apr 3, 2:30pm

Also …

Dan

Apr 3, 9:32pm

None of us were expecting a National Championship at that point.

Blue Print

Apr 4, 8:52pm

I also watched it happen

Dan

Apr 4, 11:31pm

Hard to say that when the game was a) early in the season and b) the play was

StantonMac

Apr 3, 2:38pm

Yup! For individual "I can't believe what I just saw" amazingness, Miracle Bowl

jaba166

Apr 3, 12:37am

How can something that happened in the 3rd quarter “seal the win”?

StantonMac

Apr 3, 6:15pm

Not sure which one you mean, but the Guilford Int was the last play of the game

jaba166

Apr 4, 12:30pm

“Tyler Allgeier track down and strip of ASU player to seal the win”

StantonMac

Apr 4, 1:11pm

Ah, OK, I stand corrected on that one, but that play was still probably the key

jaba166

Apr 7, 6:50pm

4th and 18

CougarLucas

Apr 3, 1:33pm

^^^THIS!^^^

icecougar

Apr 3, 7:15pm

Mostly because it was my first BYU game I ever saw/attended.

crack

Apr 2, 9:15pm

Bosco to Kelly Smith to win the Natty

B Blue

Apr 2, 9:21pm

Big moment because of the significance of the game

Belboz

Apr 2, 9:38pm

Beck's throw to Harline was a tad more miraculous than Clay Brown's catch.

Threw and Through

Apr 3, 10:57am

Sure, but Kyle Morrell's sack beats both.

Belboz

Apr 3, 11:37am

McMahon to Brown beats Beck to Harline in every way.

Y05

Apr 3, 2:34pm

You're comparing apples to oranges. Beck's throw has never been done before or

Threw and Through

Apr 3, 9:32pm

If you are comparing Koz and Matthews to Brown, then there are several we could

Y05

Apr 4, 3:17am

Watched it about 10 yards away, sitting on bleachers in the corner of the endzon

Acorn

Apr 3, 7:05am

Bohanon deep post to Lassiter to win his 2nd B12 championship

Cooouuugs

Apr 3, 7:46am

You’re projecting again

CallSign

Apr 3, 8:56pm

Detmer evading two Miami defenders, who then collide into themselves, and then the pass parts the sea in the end zone.

BW84

Apr 3, 8:53am

Not just defenders. Outland Trophy winner and HOFer Maryland.

Apr 3, 10:21am

In what world is our first and miraculous

bigjohn

Apr 3, 10:35am

In the real world, that's where. I rather beat Utah in the regular season

Threw and Through

Apr 3, 11:03am

This is absurd!

bigjohn

Apr 3, 10:21pm

Wow, talk about hyperbole

StantonMac

Apr 3, 10:45pm

This is the obvious winner:

Apr 3, 12:00pm

Never forget, BSU scored 0 points off of that failed fake punt.

Pollster

Apr 3, 8:26pm

1984 vs Mich. Bosco pass to Kazlowski in back of end zone

Apr 3, 1:52pm

The Tyler Allgeier tomahawk punch will always be an all time fav for me

TaysomJimmerEraCoug

Apr 3, 2:03pm

Merlin Robertson was out of bounds.

CallSign

Apr 3, 8:02pm

RE: Merlin Robertson was out of bounds.

TaysomJimmerEraCoug

Apr 3, 9:43pm

It's between Linehan's fake punt out of the end zone vs. Boise or Jake Heaps'

cougarfan84

Apr 3, 2:05pm

RE: It's between Linehan's fake punt out of the end zone vs. Boise or Jake

Cletus the Fetus

Apr 3, 7:12pm

The best drive was Doman’s in LaVell’s last game against Utah. A miracle drive.

cougERdoc

Apr 3, 3:01pm

Fred Warner deserves a mention here.

Y05

Apr 4, 3:35am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad