Even if Kama's comment is TIC, I'll adopt it as my own. He'll end

Apr 16, 2014
3:37:35pm

riboflavin

up as top 5 at BYU, but there is a fair argument that he isn't there yet. People are drastically underestimating how good Harvey was.

Report problem with this ad

riboflavin

Previous username: the_format
Bio page: riboflavin
Joined: Oct 5, 2006
Last login: May 4, 2024
Total posts: 79,719 (48,570 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: I would trade Jamaal Williams for Harvey Unga this year.

Undefeated

4/16/14 3:01pm

<< Deleted >>

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 3:02pm

Most years I would. But Jamal fits this current O better.

The Lone Wolf

4/16/14 3:05pm

I would trade Jamaal Williams' O-line for Harvey Unga's O-line

billyrust

4/16/14 3:06pm

Exactly.

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 3:13pm

For Harvey in his prime? Absolutely. I hope most that voted are forgetting that

Walter Bellhaven

4/16/14 3:21pm

+1. His size and elusiveness made him a joy to watch. Special player.

riboflavin

4/16/14 3:25pm

I love Unga but Jamaal will actually play in the NFL

Cougarealist

4/16/14 3:29pm

Which current NFL player most closely resembles Jamaal?

riboflavin

4/16/14 3:34pm

A poor mans Shady McCoy.

Shimmy

4/16/14 3:43pm

very poor. I think he looks more like Stevan Ridley w/o the fumbles.

Belboz

4/16/14 3:44pm

I think a poor man's Matt Forte

CoopDizz

4/16/14 3:59pm

Could Jamaal play in the NFL this year?

Walter Bellhaven

4/16/14 3:39pm

I don't believe so, no.

Heinz57

4/16/14 8:05pm

he also had several of his OL go on to play on Sundays in the NFL...

icecougar

4/16/14 7:31pm

I don't think NFL teams take that into account when they draft a guy.

Walter Bellhaven

4/16/14 9:43pm

I love JSwag but he is not YET close to being the running back that Harvey was.

Kama'aina

4/16/14 3:30pm

RE: I love JSwag but he is not YET close to being the running back that Harvey

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 3:34pm

Even if Kama's comment is TIC, I'll adopt it as my own. He'll end

riboflavin

4/16/14 3:37pm

RE: Even if Kama's comment is TIC, I'll adopt it as my own. He'll end

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 3:45pm

kama is a really good dude, so i'm not worried about the personality stuff.

riboflavin

4/16/14 3:50pm

Okay

CoopDizz

4/16/14 4:17pm

That clears it up.

PolarisPrime

4/16/14 4:36pm

RE: That clears it up.

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 4:47pm

I agree, but its still fun to consider and make comparisons.

PolarisPrime

4/16/14 4:54pm

RE: I agree, but its still fun to consider and make comparisons.

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 5:06pm

Not intended as a cheap shot. I personally find JSwag and his personality

Kama'aina

4/16/14 3:51pm

Settle down. Don't get so worked up.

messi

4/16/14 4:00pm

Not TIC. I have no doubt that he CAN end up ther but not YET.

Kama'aina

4/16/14 3:44pm

Kama knows his stuff, no worries about what Kama said

Heinz57

4/16/14 8:04pm

He was GREAT last year

CoopDizz

4/16/14 4:05pm

Harvey beats JW on size, escape moves, punishing defenders, and catching ability

Cougarclaw

4/16/14 3:48pm

RE: Harvey beats JW on size, escape moves, punishing defenders, and catching

southernfriedcougar

4/16/14 3:51pm

Williams def has a push, but he won't run over you. drag? yes. Punish? no.

Cougarclaw

4/16/14 3:56pm

Harvey was the man. He was a Ute killer. I will always love him for what he

The Lone Wolf

4/16/14 4:00pm

Only looking at last 20 years I'd take Luke, Jenkins, Harvey, Curtis, thenJamaal

Yakov

4/16/14 3:58pm

I might make it Staley, Harvey, Brown, Jenkins

PolarisPrime

4/16/14 4:40pm

Luke was waaaaay too injury prone

Blueto

4/16/14 7:52pm

But so fun to watch

AF Cougar

4/17/14 6:12am

Do we get a fullback in this trade? Harvey needs a FB

BW84

4/16/14 4:04pm

BYU did a good job at keeping this fact from the Chicago Bears

Walter Bellhaven

4/16/14 4:10pm

To break free yes..

PolarisPrime

4/16/14 4:55pm

I'd take Fui in short yardage situations

stoils

4/16/14 5:38pm

before the high ankle injury and surgery...

icecougar

4/16/14 7:37pm

True. I think Fui before that ankle injury MAY have been better than Harvey

Non-mo Coug

4/16/14 10:06pm

He was definately fun to watch when he ran into the line as a freshman.

PolarisPrime

4/16/14 11:33pm

RE: POLL: I would trade Jamaal Williams for Harvey Unga this year.

kbufcoug

4/16/14 5:09pm

Harvey is the slower of the two

Mars

4/16/14 5:53pm

Robert mentions that as one of Harvey strengths...

Heinz57

4/16/14 8:44pm

Is this the most votes ever on a poll?

byuluvr

4/16/14 9:31pm

Too early to say... Let's see after JAMAAL has 3 yrs under his belt like Harvey

Posting on CougarBoard