I'd say Peyton Manning is the best regular season QB of all-time.

Apr 16, 2014
10:04:06pm

jreid191

When factoring post-season performance, that's where Montana passes him up due to what you said above. In my opinion the conversation pretty much ends after those two.

Report problem with this ad

jreid191

Bio page: jreid191
Joined: Mar 8, 2003
Last login: Apr 29, 2024
Total posts: 17,035 (655 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Best QB of all time?

BYUCougarsFan

4/16/14 9:32pm

Jim McMahon could have been a HoF player had he not had Charles Martin not blow

CougDogg-e-Dogg

4/16/14 9:36pm

I think Jimmy Mac could have been a Hall of Fame caliber QB

eddog

4/16/14 9:37pm

Yep, it's Montana. He doesn't get the credit

messi

4/16/14 9:42pm

Dang, I'm a hack

Fatalplacebo

4/16/14 9:44pm

I know one thing that's not debatable,

messi

4/16/14 9:39pm

Montana lost some by being a jerk to Steve Young

The Shazad

4/16/14 10:25pm

He also has the most virulent detractors

CoopDizz

4/16/14 10:34pm

I would argue the opposite. He is probably the most

messi

4/16/14 10:44pm

These deserve a mention...

So it goes...

4/16/14 9:43pm

Montana went 4 for 4 in his Super Bowls with multiple MVPs.

Fatalplacebo

4/16/14 9:43pm

I'd say Peyton Manning is the best regular season QB of all-time.

jreid191

4/16/14 10:04pm

Yep, easily

The Shazad

4/16/14 10:24pm

Peyton Manning? I'm a fan, but come on.

Shimmy

4/16/14 9:47pm

seriously.. best regular season QB

nzkiwi

4/16/14 10:20pm

Marino.

spugeddy24

4/16/14 9:47pm

I think this was the biggest name I missed...

BYUCougarsFan

4/16/14 10:02pm

Johnny Unitas should be in this list as well

rebelCoug

4/16/14 9:54pm

I'm a big Niners fan, but I still gotta give it to Elway.

OpusX

4/16/14 10:04pm

Bart Starr has the most titles

CoopDizz

4/16/14 10:34pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad