1. It trashes players that played injured trying to help the team.....it's happened to Riley, PoVey, Yeck, Fusi....etc.
2. It discounts the fact that 3 of those dudes are healthy (or healthier) and have shown very well in the spring.
3. The comments are not based on any personal observation of spring practice (as far as I can tell).
Based on what I've seen, in person, I am very confident you are wrong about some of these dudes.