Fellowship, by a mile.

Sep 23, 2014
9:58:42am

ebv

It was probably the greatest cinematic experience of my life. Wonderful movie, well acted, and faithful enough to the books without being slavishly devoted to every detail. Pretty much a perfect movie in my mind.

Report problem with this ad

ebv

Bio page: ebv
Joined: Jan 12, 2011
Last login: Apr 27, 2024
Total posts: 11,880 (678 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: best tolkien/jackson movie:

nashty

9/23/14 9:42am

Action Jackson

Bobby Dooley

9/23/14 9:43am

I rewatched that a couple weeks ago. Just as lame now as it was then.

John Doe

9/23/14 9:58am

the fellowship and two towers are 10/10

HONKYTONKMAN

9/23/14 9:45am

He's butchered The Hobbit. Everything from Radagast riding a sled pulled by

srey

9/23/14 9:45am

Agree, but I still watch them.

Banjo Blues

9/23/14 9:49am

well how else are you supposed to fill up 10 hours of time?

nashty

9/23/14 11:57am

The Hobbit 5: The Search for More Money

uberslacker

9/23/14 9:50am

Can't believe Return of the King is beating Two Towers.

byujacob

9/23/14 9:52am

The right answer is Fellowship

Freddie Cougar

9/23/14 9:55am

It was ROTK that killed my desire to watch any of the Hobbit. Awful movie.

Blue Print

9/23/14 9:56am

Which part of the movie is the intolerable Deus Ex Machina for you?

ebv

9/23/14 9:57am

The Battle of Pelennor Fields:

byujacob

9/23/14 10:01am

And what I didn't get is if they were going to use the Army of the Dead in that

Texas Hammer

9/23/14 10:10am

Yeah, Aragorn totally didn't have "it" with that whiff. Very Anae-like

gaspasscoug

9/23/14 10:40am

Fair enough; I remember being mildly upset by that.

ebv

9/23/14 10:18am

Yeah, I think I like Two Towers better than Return of the King.

byujacob

9/23/14 10:22am

But Two Towers has a couple of pretty glaring absurdities as well

Freddie Cougar

9/23/14 12:08pm

Idk...elves are amazing creatures. Seems plausible.

Texas Hammer

9/23/14 10:39am

Fellowship, by a mile.

ebv

9/23/14 9:58am

That one with the ring and a Frodo in it.

John Doe

9/23/14 9:59am

The Godfather?

TNT

9/23/14 10:12am

Yeah, I think that's the one.

John Doe

9/23/14 10:14am

Oh wait. That was Fredo

Posting on CougarBoard