I play in 10 team leagues exclusively. In 10 team leagues, there's almost no reason to have two QBs except for when QB1 is on his bye week.

Regardless, I've found myself with Tom Brady and Cam Newton on my roster this week.

In that same league, there's a guy with Kaepernick and no other QB.
Guys like Flacco and Tannehill are available. I'd bet on Brady outperforming either of them. He's been much better since Gronk regained his form.


So I have an extra QB and he needs a QB.
I asked him if he was interested in a trade. After looking over his roster, I saw that nothing would really work.
He then told me that he'd just drop one of his TEs to grab a QB for this week.
He has Dwayne Allen and Jimmy Graham.
So I asked "Which one?"

He pointed at Jimmy Graham,

He also has Ryan Matthews on his roster. I immediately told him that dropping Matthews or maybe even Allen would make a lot more sense.

So he asked if I'd take Graham for Tom Brady....


I'm accused of making dirty deals in this work league every single year. My team's name this year is No Shady Deals and it's not merely because I have LeSean McCoy.


So how dirty am I if accept his offer?
I've considered throwing in Vernon Davis as well.

Graham has been hurt. He played a little on Sunday but didn't record a single catch while being targeted twice.
How dirty is it?

Is it unethical for me to take a trade like that even after making my best effort by recommending that he merely drop Allen or Matthews instead?