This is measured every year by the Director's Cup. Here are the finishes year by year for BYU and Utah over the past 5. Utah is never as high as BYU/
2013-14 BYU 42, Utah 72
2012-13 BYU 43, Utah 77
2011-12 BYU 43, Utah 74
2010-11 BYU 37, Utah 71
2009-10 BYU 36, Utah 75