Reason 1 But plays no defense other than winder and Bartley and Bartley doesn't even play,which he should because of his defensive ability. Rose continues to recruit shooters who can't play defense. As we have seen shooting comes and goes each game. But good defensive Players are consistent every game. Its been said more than once defensive wins championships and it doesn't matter which sport your talking about. It is an absolute must to recruit better athletes and less spot up shooters ex haws, toolson, cavlert, zylstra.

Reason 2 post game is a joke, they can't score rebound or play defense, you can't win games that way.

Reason 3 they play in the wcc which is a bad conference and lose games each year to teams that should not even be on the floor against byu. Its tough to swallo to see teams like SD and pepperdine have better athletes than byu so byu has to play zone because in man the opposing players get right to the basket.

Conclusion rose deserves the critizism because he is the head coach he recruits the kids and runs the system. If your satisfied with a coach that never wins a conference title and usually always loses in the first round of th ncaa tourn then rose is your guy