I think that BYU is making the right decision here. The events that passed that are being characterized here as off field issues are more than that. It was a reoccurring issue and would have damaged the kid had it been widely known. To the credit of BYU coaches they have kept it under wraps and the info is not wide spread I have even spoken to coaches from other schools who were recruiting him and they were puzzled as to why BYU hadn't offered.. BYU kept this info under wraps. Good for BYU