BYU is not in the Pac 12 Yewtah is. That helps yewts recruit vs BYU.
The yewts have a better home schedule than BYU and that helps yewts recruit instate kids vs BYU
BYU seems to get some better recruits in other states. Maybe because of ESPN and "Exposure"
Do i think BYU is imploding? No, but they are losing ground in state and it's all perception. All this crap about legacy kids and upset alum is a joke. Kids get caught up in the hype just like everyone else.
I do think BYU had improved is position since the MWC days. Going back would damage the program do much more than staying Indy. That said, BYU has to take the next step. Change what you control and BYU controls pay and choosing. Up your coaches pay, get aggressive and bring in great minds and recruiters. This is a business, act like it is.