Not really. It is a sign of a good team. Personally, the mvp

Jan 31, 2015
9:11:50pm

Baron

is a dumb award in my IMO. It means different things to different people. Have a best player award. And for football it should be best offensive skill player, best defensive back 7 and best lineman award. Can't really compare across those positions.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jan 31, 2015 at 9:11:50pm

Message modified by Baron on Jan 31, 2015 at 9:36:32pm

Report problem with this ad

Baron

Previous username: jarocho
Bio page: Baron
Joined: Sep 1, 2006
Last login: Apr 29, 2024
Total posts: 94,010 (32,687 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Aaron Rodgers wins the MVP. JJ Watt was robbed.

Texas Hammer

1/31/15 8:15pm

Has there ever been a MVP whose team didn't make the playoffs, any major sport?

swishh_15

1/31/15 8:16pm

OJ won it in Buffalo in early 70's and they didnt make playoffs

BlueFrog

1/31/15 8:18pm

Dale Murphy - 1983

ORCoug

1/31/15 8:40pm

That is a stupid requirement especially for football.

Baron

1/31/15 8:52pm

It's not a requirement but a sign there are probably more valuable players

swishh_15

1/31/15 9:01pm

Not really. It is a sign of a good team. Personally, the mvp

Baron

1/31/15 9:11pm

The best player gets his team to the playoffs. Take Rodgers off the packers and

swishh_15

1/31/15 9:37pm

In football the best QB gets his team to the playoffs. This is true. Watt is not

TrueAndBlue

1/31/15 9:40pm

Then he isn't "The most valuable player" is he?

swishh_15

1/31/15 9:43pm

By virtue of being a QB the QB will always win the argument. But Watt is the

TrueAndBlue

1/31/15 9:55pm

The QB is by default the MVP on each team. Bottom line it is a stupid award in

Baron

1/31/15 9:49pm

I'm trying to think of a year where the best QB didn't make the playoffs. I

TrueAndBlue

1/31/15 9:57pm

It happens in baseball

fredgarvin

1/31/15 9:43pm

I think baseball is the only sport where these kind of awards matter. And I

TrueAndBlue

1/31/15 9:58pm

Romo and Murray tied for third!

Japan Coug

1/31/15 8:23pm

The difference between Watt and the second best player at his position was

messi

1/31/15 8:24pm

Rodgers. Easily the best player in the most important position. Watt is great,

Japan Coug

1/31/15 8:28pm

Well, the Texans do need a QB. I like Watt as both a player and a person.

Texas Hammer

1/31/15 8:31pm

Fixed. Meant to say QB is the most important position in sports.

messi

1/31/15 9:36pm

JJ Watt is the best football player on the planet. Rodgers was the best QB

TrueAndBlue

1/31/15 9:36pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad