I guess I take a broader view that "elite" encompasses all of college football,

Mar 31, 2015
2:47:03pm

Mikey

not just BYU. I believe Collie and to some extent Hoffman were "elite" in college football. I wouldn't necessarily call them "all-time" in that respect. Considering BYU receivers only, they are certainly in the "all-time" discussion.

Report problem with this ad

Mikey

Bio page: Mikey
Joined: Jul 12, 2002
Last login: Apr 29, 2024
Total posts: 16,472 (950 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I got a good chuckle yesterday when Spencer Linton on BYU Sports Nation

acougfan

3/31/15 11:42am

I don't think he's elite either. But who is better on the team?

Lance71

3/31/15 11:44am

I don't know yet, I haven't seen enough of anyone to say who is the best

acougfan

3/31/15 11:45am

lol then what the heck makes you think he won't be the best?

southernfriedcougar

3/31/15 11:48am

seems like he's just taking the field instead of betting on one. No harm in that

Cougforgood

3/31/15 1:25pm

I'm just asking where the reason is.

southernfriedcougar

3/31/15 2:04pm

I hope you're right. If Mathews is as good as he was last year, and we have a

Lance71

3/31/15 11:49am

Elite is relative in my view. Is he elite relative to many BYU receivers in past

BlackBart

3/31/15 11:45am

I think there have only been two (and a good case for only one). Collie and Hoff

Mikey

3/31/15 11:51am

So, "elite" equates to "all-time"? I guess I look at it as two separate levels

BlackBart

3/31/15 12:18pm

I guess I take a broader view that "elite" encompasses all of college football,

Mikey

3/31/15 2:47pm

well what did you think when taysom said he's the best in the country?

johnnycarson

3/31/15 11:46am

Like I said I like Matthews , I guess I just have a different definition

acougfan

3/31/15 11:50am

May not hold much weight but Fred Warner disagrees with you

P-Boy Squad

3/31/15 11:46am

If Mitch learns how to run routes better this year then he could

kimdaddy35

3/31/15 11:51am

"could be"...yes, sounds like that's a real possibility. "is"...not yet.

nashty

3/31/15 11:53am

I'll be very surprised if he's not our best WR this year (barring injury)

Left Shark Coug

3/31/15 11:55am

Disagree. Think he's elite and a top 10 national WR.

cougfanz

3/31/15 12:21pm

Top 10? Woah.

southernfriedcougar

3/31/15 12:33pm

I think he has elite tools, potential, but we have only seen glimpses

Bob Vance

3/31/15 1:24pm

Kind of agree

Posting on CougarBoard