No, that was a block for sure

May 21, 2015
10:25:28pm

kimdaddy35

I was talking about a call where Harden went through Green and got a foul. Both Jackson and Van Gundy talked about being set and that Green wasn't set.

Report problem with this ad

kimdaddy35

Bio page: kimdaddy35
Joined: Aug 23, 2010
Last login: May 1, 2024
Total posts: 46,422 (1,476 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

It astounds me that two former NBA coaches don't know the difference

kimdaddy35

5/21/15 10:12pm

Or maybe the 2 former coaches are right and the random internet poster is wrong?

Japan Coug

5/21/15 10:16pm

Whoa. And so it begins....

TNT

5/21/15 10:18pm

So the rule book is wrong?

kimdaddy35

5/21/15 10:24pm

No, but possibly some interpretations of it are wrong.

Japan Coug

5/22/15 4:03am

Check page 45

kimdaddy35

5/21/15 10:32pm

I did, and I'm no more convinced than I was before. I don't see any mention of

Japan Coug

5/22/15 4:01am

Lol so you're convinced that a defenders feet have to be set

byubyu

5/22/15 7:56am

No, I'm saying that there is no such rule regarding "secondary defenders," and

Japan Coug

5/22/15 8:30am

And their judgment was it was a blocking foul because

byubyu

5/22/15 9:05am

If it was the play I'm thinking of, it was definitely a blocking foul IMO.

Japan Coug

5/22/15 11:52am

Sorry that you don't understand English well

kimdaddy35

5/22/15 12:23pm

What are you quoting? I don't see any of the latter part on the page you

Japan Coug

5/22/15 12:46pm

It was later on in the rule book, page 58 if I remember correctly

kimdaddy35

5/22/15 1:07pm

So if you can't move toward the opponent either directly or obliquely, that

Japan Coug

5/22/15 3:10pm

You can move from side to side as long as it is not at an angle towards

kimdaddy35

5/22/15 3:35pm

The problem is that moving sideways will almost always move you obliquely

Japan Coug

5/22/15 9:40pm

which play are you taking about?

bulletproof

5/21/15 10:18pm

No, that was a block for sure

kimdaddy35

5/21/15 10:25pm

I had the same thought when they said that. Clearly they were wrong.

byubyu

5/21/15 10:46pm

Nevertheless, it was clearly a foul on Green

wapiti

5/21/15 11:42pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad