The only year BM has posted double digit wins was in 2011, against a schedule packed with WAC teams that had just moved to the MWC. 2012 features a similar schedule, but with 2 more losses.

Here is BYU's records for the last 5 years:

2010: 7-6
2011: 10-3 (this was the first year of Indy and BYU played mostly former WAC teams)
2012: 8-5 (similar schedule to 2011, but with losses to SJSU and Oregon State)
2013: 8-5 (first good schedule in Indy)
2014: 8-5

2015: 8-5 would be a pretty good record against this schedule

I'm not sure why you are bragging about a record that manages 2 wins above .500 a year.