It's not about being "too mean", it's about proportionate punishment

Report problem with this ad

Oct 6, 2015
9:05:02am

Indy Coug

for the crime. If we adopt your proposal, going from the 50 to only the 35 on a personal foul is being too nice.

Report problem with this ad

Indy Coug

Bio page: Indy Coug
Joined: Dec 20, 2001
Last login: May 10, 2024
Total posts: 184,920 (9,841 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

As long as we're on this topic, the football rule that makes no sense to me is

smokymountainrain

10/6/15 8:54am

Totally agree.

foofcoug

10/6/15 8:56am

it's almost as if the justification is that they don't want to be too mean.

smokymountainrain

10/6/15 8:58am

What would happen if you intentionally grounded at the 1? Spot or half the dist?

frontrowcougar

10/6/15 9:08am

it's always the spot on an intentional grounding, so the spot.

smokymountainrain

10/6/15 9:11am

At some point, it has to become half the distance

Indy Coug

10/6/15 8:57am

No, it doesn't have to become half the distance.

smokymountainrain

10/6/15 9:02am

It's not about being "too mean", it's about proportionate punishment

Indy Coug

10/6/15 9:05am

The distance has to be changed at some point.

SpiffCoug

10/6/15 9:05am

again, if the penalty is for more yards than what you have possible

smokymountainrain

10/6/15 9:13am

I've always thought inside the 10, they should move the chains

zuxvon

10/6/15 10:13am

That's an interesting suggestion. I could consider that.

SpiffCoug

10/6/15 10:25am

So if a 15 yard penalty happens at the 14 yard line

Bronoc

10/6/15 9:01am

move it back to just outside the goal line.

smokymountainrain

10/6/15 9:03am

I agree. I've always wondered this, too. I was hoping to read an argument here

Posting on CougarBoard