I have to agree with this.

Nov 30, 2015
12:00:20pm

buhler08 All-American

Any 1-loss P5 team (ND included) will be ranked above any undefeated non-P% team, and there would be a lot of debate about 2 loss teams.

Report problem with this ad

buhler08

New username: CougarBlue08
Bio page: buhler08
Joined: Feb 13, 2003
Last login: Jan 29, 2017
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Does a 13-0 BYU AAC Conference Champ make the Playoff?

yfootball

11/30/15 11:38am

No way anyone outside the P-5 makes the playoff

CasualFan

11/30/15 11:44am

I have to agree with this.

buhler08

11/30/15 12:00pm

Week 9 Memphis is the proof

CasualFan

11/30/15 12:07pm

Memphis had not played any of their more difficult in conference games yet.

Josef K

11/30/15 12:16pm

LOL. Just LOL.

CasualFan

11/30/15 12:19pm

Ehh. Okay.

Josef K

11/30/15 12:31pm

Memphis would be at best 7 right now

buhler08

11/30/15 12:37pm

not according to the Playoff Comittee criteria.

Josef K

11/30/15 12:46pm

Ummm, MSU is favored to win the Big Ten Championship on Saturday

buhler08

11/30/15 12:48pm

Yeah, that's kind of an important point. But it doesn't chang the analysis much.

Josef K

11/30/15 12:57pm

Probably need a better OOC schedule than those 3

pink22

11/30/15 11:46am

If you want that you have to accept many more one and dones than even today.

TaiJuan

11/30/15 11:50am

<< Deleted >>

yfootball

11/30/15 11:51am

Looking at this year as an example, I would say no.

cougarfan84

11/30/15 12:19pm

only with a great year (10-2 or better) before to set it up. we'd have to start

byujag

11/30/15 12:45pm

It would be close. Perhaps more importantly, BYU would be at least Fiesta-bound

boscatar

11/30/15 12:59pm

Good points.

Posting on CougarBoard