It was after his sophomore season and It was not long after the Holiday Bowl loss to Penn State (still the best BYU game I've been to where they lost). I used to live just south of campus in a house known as the Man Hole and I was eating lunch over at the Tommy's that was where the J Dawgs is now (on 700 East) munching on a chili burger. I look over and there is Ty. Never being a shy guy, I struck up a conversation abut the Holiday bowl game. I remember saying something like I thought his knee was down before they ripped the ball out and returned it for the game winning touchdown. He said, "Naw, it was a good play. They got me." We chatted for a couple minutes and then I left. He was very gracious about it.